On 27th December Lancaster Guardian featured an article by reporter Robbie Macdonald ‘Student flat plans for historic Lancaster locations’.
The full article can be read at Student Flats
The planning Scrutiny Group of Lancaster Civic Vision felt that a response to this article was appropriate and has written the below letter to Lancaster Guardian for publication:
Student flats in Lancaster.
Your feature highlights the fact that over recent years major changes have been taking place in the townscape of Lancaster as a consequence of the construction of a large number of purpose-built student accommodation blocks.
Lancaster Civic Vision, as a “statutory consultee” has been closely monitoring these developments. In many cases we have welcomed the bringing back into use of brown-field sites and derelict buildings which had become embarrassing eyesores.
We have frequently pleaded (often to no avail) for a reduction in height of some of the larger structures. Strong objections were expressed to the construction of two blocks alongside the Carlisle Bridge on the Quay, and to the development of the disused Filter House site on the A6, south if the city. Both of our objections were unsuccessful.
We have been pleased to recognise the efforts of some developers to respect original features of many Lancaster’s heritage buildings in their conversions e.g. – the Waring and Gillows shop on North Road, a Georgian-style house in Cable Street and some similar residences on St. Leonard’s Gate.
Unfortunately, the development (also in St Leonard’s Gate) in your illustration (below) we find unacceptable, since the design fails to emulate the façade of the adjoining building, going so far as to insert a false front doorway.

Lancaster Civic Vision is also concerned that the city could soon be facing a glut of such accommodation, much of which could not then be used for other purposes. In common with Lancaster University we have sought evidence from the City Council of current and future demand, in the belief that developments already completed or under consideration could exceed requirements The current uncertainties about the impact of leaving the EU, the possibility that countries such as China could choose to expand their own institutions, might all contribute to an uncertain future for the high-end studio flats which are now being marketed.
Civic Vision recognises the considerable contribution made by our universities to the local economy but has to warn against the danger of “putting all the eggs into one basket”. We would like to see developers divert their efforts into providing affordable housing for those struggling to gain a foothold on the property market.
Lancaster Civic Vision – 4th January 2022
Lancaster Civic Vision is the operating name of Lancaster Civic Society – Registered Charity 258434 – and its subgroup Lancaster Vision


