Protecting Lancaster’s Heritage

A pictorial history of Kingsway – 2004 – 2009

One of the prime objectives of Lancaster Civic Vision is “To encourage high standards of architecture and town planning” and as such – and as a Civic Society – we are a statutory consultee on planning issues which are under consideration by Lancaster City Council.

Our Planning Scrutiny Group, a sub group which is made up of a proportion of members of Civic Vision, are regularly notified of all planning applications received by Lancaster City Planning Department.

After discussion among the group, comments and recommendations are made to the Planning Department, particularly in relation to proposals regarding Listed Buildings, and those within the City Conservation Areas are closely monitored in an effort to influence good design.

Through the efforts of this Group Lancaster Civic Vision seeks to protect and enhance the existing townscape of our fine city and to try and ensure that developers, architects, builders and planners remain true to the unique nature of the City and its surrounding landscape.

However, as can be seen from the history of Kingsway from 2004 to today, our best efforts are not always sufficient to ensure that success is guaranteed.

From the Government Department of Digital, Culture, Media & Sport’s document ‘What Listing Means’ we understand that the main purpose of listing a building is ‘to ensure that care will be taken over decisions affecting its future’, and ‘that any alterations respect the particular character and interest of the building’.

The following photographic records demonstrate quite graphically a total disregard for the particular character and interest of these buildings, preserving merely part of the facades which have no function apart from their appearance.

The entrances are no longer entrances; the walls no longer support or enclose anything!

We also note from ‘What Listing Means‘ that ‘buildings are listed in their entirety: there is no such thing as a listed facade….’.

Lancaster Civic Vision very much support this view.

Kingsway 2004

The outline application for conversion of this Grade II listed building was submitted with not even a single elevation drawing – this for a building that would be several times the height of any other building in the vicinity!

So we decided to make our own:

Lancaster Civic Society alternative design for Kingsway development 2004

An alternative design was submitted by David Howard

Original entrance to the Kingsway swimming baths
Work is underway – 2005
The reality 2009

Did English Heritage really approve the design of this building, prominently sited at the entrance to what they subsequently described as ‘The Bath of the North’?

The building as it looks today

Is this eyesore, attached as it is to a listed facade, now itself a listed building?