Preston and Lancaster residents ‘want new hospitals close to home’ in seeming snub to super hospital alternative

The majority of people who have given their opinion on the futures of the Royal Preston Hospital and Royal Lancaster Infirmary say that they want to keep the facilities close to where they currently live, the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) can reveal.

by Paul Faulkner, Lancaster Guardian – 27th November 2021

A public engagement process inviting comments on a “longlist” of ten possible options for the sites closed earlier month.

It was carried out as part of the development of a bid to secure government cash for either two replacement buildings for each of the ageing hospitals or the creation of one so-called “super hospital” in a central location.

The latter concept does not so far seem to have found much favour in the public mindset – although if it were to be pursued, some local services would be retained in new integrated centres in Preston and Lancaster.

It looks like residents want a replacement for each of the Royal Preston and Royal Lancaster hospitals – but there is a long way to go yet before anything is decided

Lancashire was identified last year as one of 40 areas where the government had pledged to create new hospitals or extensively refurbish existing facilities.

While the county was given the two broad options of whether to construct one or two new buildings, the Lancashire and South Cumbria New Hospitals Programme subsequently came up with ten possible permutations to pitch to the government and the public.

These included the rebuilding of the Royal Preston and Royal Lancaster on their current sites or entirely new plots – as well as the prospect of a super hospital serving both Central Lancashire and North Lancashire/South Cumbria. Speculation has previously swirled around Garstang as a possible location for a single new hospital.

While analysis of the feedback given during the engagement process is ongoing and a quantifiable assessment of the public’s inclination has not yet been published, the head of Lancashire and South Cumbria’s New Hospitals Programme told the LDRS that it appeared “most respondents had a preference to keep the hospital close to wherever they were currently resident”.

Jerry Hawker, senior responsible officer for the programme, added: “Preston residents were keen to keep [their hospital] close to the centre of Preston and Lancaster residents were keen to keep [theirs] where it was. South Cumbria residents [asked]: ‘Can we move it a little bit further up?’”

That sentiment – captured in almost 3,000 online responses and hundreds more engagements at a series of 16 roadshows held across the region – echoes the results of separate polling carried out into the public’s thoughts on the issue of new hospital facilities in the region.

A recent meeting of the Lancashire and South Cumbria Integrated Care System (ICS) board heard that the outcome of that survey indicated that “people north and south of the region do not wish to travel in either direction for anything but the most complex treatments and [even then] for no more than an hour”.

Mr. Hawker said he was “not surprised” by the finding and revealed that residents in Ribble Valley and South Cumbria had expressed particular concern about the possible journey times to hospital under the various propositions.

“[There] has been quite consistent feedback from members of the public that the time it takes them to get to hospital is important to them. I am pleased that people do recognise that if they are going [to hospital] for more specialist reasons, it’s more acceptable to travel.

“Clearly, that would put an emphasis towards retaining the two hospital sites as being more preferable to the public than perhaps to have a single new super hospital built in the middle.

“Of course, we haven’t made any decisions on any of the options yet or [on] any sites, but it’s still very good to have that feedback and recognise that travel time is an important consideration for us to take into account,” Mr. Hawker explained.

According to the list of the government’s 40 hospital projects published last year, three urgent care hubs would also be provided in the event that a single new hospital were created for Central and North Lancashire/South Cumbria.

The engagement feedback will now be gathered and assessed against considerations including cost and outcomes for patients before the options are whittled down to a shortlist. The ICS meeting heard that “key products” had been developed in order to help create the business case that will ultimately have to be put to the government to secure the cash – and that these include a methodology for the shortlisting process.

Mr. Hawker said at the outset of the initial engagement period that coming up with a chosen option would be “a balance between what is the right thing for the population, what is feasible to do and what’s affordable”.

The LDRS understands that the shortlist is likely to be published in the first quarter of next year. If any of the options that could be pursued are deemed to constitute a major change to NHS services, a formal public consultation would have to be carried out. That is unlikely to occur until next summer because of the so-called “purdah” rules that would prevent it happening in the run-up to next year’s local elections.

Public consultation would be required for both the super hospital option and the rebuilding of either the Royal Preston or Royal Lancaster on sites away from those which they currently occupy.

Mr. Hawker stressed that even if the eventual shortlist meant a formal consultation was not needed, the NHS would continue to engage with the public so that the eventual chosen option is “owned by the people of Lancashire and South Cumbria”.

It is hoped that building work on one or more projects would begin in 2025 and the new facilities be open by 2030.

The region’s New Hospitals Programme published its “case for change” earlier this year – setting out the reasons why Preston and Lancaster were in need of new facilities.

For the Royal Preston, they included a staggering £157m backlog of maintenance work and inadequate operating theatre capacity. For the Royal Lancaster, an £88m maintenance backlog and accessibility problems were amongst the issues highlighted.

A reduction in health inequalities and the improvement of staff recruitment and retention were also identified as overarching aims of the programme.

The government has so far committed £3.7bn to its list of planned hospital projects – which is currently in the process of being expanded to 48. However, it has been estimated that in excess of £20bn will ultimately be required as the schemes are approved and taken forward.

Earlier this month, the Health Service Journal magazine reported that the Infrastructure and Projects Authority (IPA) watchdog had downgraded the nationwide new hospitals programme to a “red” rating – defined as a project that “appears to be unachievable”.

In response, the Department for Health and Social Care said that it was “addressing the IPA’s recommendations in detail” and was “fully committed to the delivery of all 48 hospitals by 2030”.

Mr. Hawker said that the feedback across Lancashire and South Cumbria to date consistently showed a public belief that both Preston and Lancaster hospitals “urgently need investing in”.

He added that ever-evolving technology and changes to the way healthcare is delivered meant that the region needed to “future-proof” its proposal for new facilities as far as possible.

“The way we treated people ten years ago is different to how we treat them today and will be different again in ten years’ time. But there are some things we are really keen to see make happen.

“We have learned a lot about infection prevention and around how people recover quicker when they are in a room on their own. So there is [a desire for people] to have greater dignity in hospital [and] have single rooms.

“When we look to the future, I think hospitals will be smaller – that’s not because we are providing less care, but technology and the way we treat people will enable us to do it in shorter periods of time [and] do more care at home.

“So I think [in] future…when you come into hospital it will be because you really need to be there and hopefully you’ll have the most advanced treatment in Lancashire that you possibly could have – that’s what excited me about the programme.

“So we can be quite brave in our vision for the future, but we’ve also got to be a bit pragmatic about affordability – we can’t have everything and there will be some compromises in this.

“But I still think we can get a fantastic solution for the people of Lancashire and South Cumbria,” Mr. Hawker said.

WHY PRESTON NEEDS A NEW HOSPITAL

These were the challenges laid out by the NHS earlier this year about the Royal Preston’s Sharoe Green Lane site.

***The condition of the facilities has reached a critical stage and, without investment, buildings and services could fail.

***Inadequate car parking, which forces 1,000 staff to park off-site and use a park and ride.

WHY LANCASTER NEEDS A NEW HOSPITAL

This is what the case for change document had to say about the Royal Lancaster Infirmary on Ashton Road.

***Much of the current site is located on a slope, which in some areas is too

steep for patients to be safely moved except by ambulance.

***Access is particularly challenging for people with a disability.

***Some of the 20 buildings that make up the hospital are separated from the main complex by public highways and several services are provided in temporary buildings offering poor quality accommodation.

***Running costs are double those of a new-build hospital.

***Single room provision is only half of the recommended standard and less than a third of the local ambition for 70 percent of patients to have single rooms.

***Inadequate car parking with just 460 spaces for more than 2,500 staff.

Source: Case for Change, Lancashire and South Cumbria New Hospitals Programme

STARTER FOR TEN

These were the “longlist” of options put to the public in recent months. They are now in the process of being whittled down to a shortlist, likely to be published early next year.

1. Business as usual and no change – a standard option required in all business cases.

2. Limited investment to address all maintenance backlogs – another standard “do minimum” option required in all business cases.

3. New Royal Lancaster Infirmary on the existing site, with partial rebuild/refurbishment of Royal Preston Hospital.

4. New Royal Lancaster Infirmary on a new site, with partial rebuild/refurbishment of Royal Preston Hospital.

5. New Royal Preston Hospital on the existing site, with partial rebuild/refurbishment of Royal Lancaster Infirmary.

6. New Royal Preston Hospital on a new site, with partial rebuild/refurbishment of Royal Lancaster Infirmary.

7. Investment at both hospitals, allowing partial rebuilding work on both existing sites.

8. New Royal Preston Hospital built on a new site, with the existing Royal Preston Hospital site retained for some services and partial rebuild of Royal Lancaster Infirmary.

9. Single new hospital on a new central site to replace both Royal Preston Hospital and Royal Lancaster Infirmary (with some local services to be retained in new integrated community centres in Preston and Lancaster).

10. Two new hospitals to replace Royal Lancaster Infirmary and Royal Preston Hospital (on new sites).

Weekend Walk – Islands in the River Lune

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet No. 84

It is not unusual for large rivers, like the Lune, to have small islands within them. Examples include the many islands in the Thames upstream from London and in the Tay both at Perth and further downstream.  Such islands may comprise mud banks or marshland, or they may be shingle and large stones. These are deposits brought down the river from erosion in the uplands and temporarily deposited midstream when the river level is low.

The next major flood will bring enough water to move some of these materials further downstream and deposit new materials, so moving and remodelling the islands. They are always in a state of flux. Nevertheless despite the fragility of their composition they can be surprisingly long-lived, eroding at one part and being renewed at another. 

The River Lune has had several islands, which this leaflet describes. The maps of the area are the best source of where the islands were, what shape they took and for how long they survived. However, the cartographic record is patchy and the surveying of the islands is sketchy at times.

Salt Ayre

Today Salt Ayre is a part of the north bank of the Lune to the west of Lancaster. It used to be an island. It was first shown on Emanuel Bowen’s map of Lancashire in 1752 and a better image is found in William Yates’s map of the county in 1787 (see below). Both were small-scale maps – much enlarged below – and so the shape and location of Salt Ayre may not be accurate.

Salt Ayre (not named but south of ‘Ovangle’ and an island mid-stream) as shown on Yates’s map of 1787

The Ordnance Survey 6-inch map surveyed in 1844/5 gives a better picture. Salt Ayre is still an island but only the narrow North Channel now separates it from the north bank of the Lune (see below). The map shows a Cuckold Island which now seems to be fully attached to the south bank.

Salt Ayre as shown on the Ordnance Survey 6-inch map surveyed in 1844/5

Green Ayre

The Green Ayre was an island on the south bank of the Lune as it flowed through Lancaster. It was a prime development site in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Speed’s town plan of Lancaster, surveyed in 1607, shows it as an undeveloped island with the narrow channel (Mill Race / Damside) that made it an island.

Speed’s map of Lancaster, surveyed in 1607, showing the Green Ayre at the top

By the time of Mackreth’s map of Lancaster, surveyed in the mid-1770s, the channel that made it an island had been bridged over and culverted so comprehensively that Green Ayre was an island only in name and memory. See Leaflet No. 79 in this series for more details about this area.

Islands at Skerton

The first clear image of the small islands in the Lune at Skerton is on Yates’s map of Lancashire in 1787, a part of which, enlarged, is shown below. It shows three islands and, by a small round symbol, the corn mill in Skerton.

Islands at Skerton in 1787 on Yates’s map

The Ordnance Survey 6-inch map surveyed in 1844/5 shows the islands in much greater detail and accuracy.

The maps for 1844/5 and 1891 show the weir that powered the corn mill (demolished in 1956) and the islands mid-stream. When you compare the two maps nearly 50 years apart, you see that: (i) the islands have survived many floods but (ii) they have changed in shape, some expanding, some narrowing and some merging with their neighbouring island.

The construction of the present-day, much higher weir in 1976/7 has contributed to the further evolution of the islands, as the Google Earth image from 2018 below shows. The new weir is clearly shown and the many small islands of the past have coalesced into one large well-wooded island, now a heronry, and a smaller island above the weir. The islands were not swept away even by the unprecedentedly high flow of the Lune during Storm Desmond in 2015.

The island in the Lune at Skerton in 2018 (Source: Google Earth)

Islands further upstream

Upstream from Caton the Lune has several small islands. Some are bare shingle banks and others have some vegetation. Some are usually true islands, and some are islands only when the river level is high, at other times being areas of shingle attached to the river bank. Floods can alter these islands’ shapes quite easily, as shown by comparing the Lune at Melling as shown on the 1844 OS map and on the Google Earth image in 2018 (see below). The earlier islands have largely disappeared, having been incorporated into the adjacent fields.

The River Lune at Melling as shown on the OS 6-inch map surveyed in 1844/5
The River Lune at Melling today (Source: Google Earth)

Doubtless the islands in the Lune will continue to evolve as the river meanders across its floodplain.

Text – Gordon  Clark. Published by Lancaster Civic Society (©2021). www.lancastercivicsociety.uk.

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over eighty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

The first event for the new season started on Wednesday 13th with Andrew Reilly from Lancaster District Heritage Group giving his new presentation ‘Railways around Lancaster & Morecambe and a recording can now be viewed on our Recordings page.

Our next event is on 8th December 2021 – Nigel Neil – ‘Record it Before it Moves!’ Lessons learned from 35 years of recording buildings in advance of conversion – meeting starts at 7:30 pm.

Nigel’s interest in archaeology began when he was 10, when his parents took him to visit the Roman city of Ampurias on the Costa Brava. They said that they “didn’t think he had the aptitude” (aka wasn’t bright enough !) to follow them into a career in medicine, and didn’t mind that there was no (financial) future in the past. He did a degree in archaeology at Edinburgh (1977) and a Master of Science in Environmental Assessment at Liverpool (1993), which he did part time while living in Salford and working at Lancaster University. 

Meetings are by Zoom on the second Wednesday of each month starting at 7:30 pm and to see our other speakers, or if you wish to join a meeting, go to our Events Calendar page.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page

Historic town and gown agreement will benefit community

An historic Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) has been signed to deepen relationships between ‘town and gown’ for the benefit of communities in the Lancaster district.

Endorsed by Lancaster City Council and Lancaster University, the aim of the agreement is to strengthen the existing collaborative relationships between the two organisations to achieve social, environmental, and economic improvements.

While the council and university already collaborate successfully on a number of important projects, including Light Up Lancaster, Eden Project North and the Mill Race Heritage Action Zone, the signing of the MoU will create new and exciting opportunities to work together and draw on university research to help find lasting solutions for local challenges.

Recent joint work has included researchers from the university’s ‘Beyond Imagination’ project working with the community to help them contribute to recommendations on how to transform social housing on the Mainway Estate in Lancaster.

The vision for the partnership will initially cover four themes; economic inclusion and prosperity, environmental sustainability, healthy, happy and connected communities, and reimagining public services.

Vice-Chancellor of Lancaster University Professor Andy Schofield (seated left) and Chief Executive of Lancaster City Council Kieran Keane sign the Memorandum of Understanding at a ceremony this week.

To achieve this vision, projects will be developed via an ‘Insights Hub’, a forum to meet, contribute ideas, collaborate, and share resources. In addition to representatives from the city council and university, the hub will also welcome contributions from public, private and community organisations.

Councillor Caroline Jackson, leader of Lancaster City Council, said: “Throughout the Covid-19 pandemic we have seen how, by working together with other organisations, the council can support and make real changes for its communities.

“As we continue the long road to recovery these relationships will become even more important if we are to rebuild our economy and create new opportunities for people and businesses.

“The city council and the university both share a vision to make the Lancaster district a thriving and collaborative place and I’m delighted to have signed this agreement to deepen our working relationship.

“We already work very closely together on a number of exciting projects and we now have the opportunity to explore additional areas and find solutions that will benefit our entire district.”

Lancaster University’s Vice-Chancellor, Professor Andy Schofield, said: “As an anchor institution we are committed to playing our civic role to the full, working closely with the city council and other partners to create positive change for our communities, businesses and the environment both here in the Morecambe Bay area and the wider North West.

“The city council and the university share a long history of working together, built on great working relationships between our two organisations, and a shared commitment to creating a thriving and vibrant place.

“This agreement gives us the opportunity to be ambitious and strengthen the district for the benefit of everyone who lives, works and visits here.

Wednesday Walk (Drive?) – On the Road in the Lancaster Area

Probably few people think of roads as ‘interesting’. Useful and sometimes congested, certainly; pleasurable or tricky to drive along, perhaps. Yet there are some roads in the Lancaster area that do have unexpectedly interesting histories and features.

Lancaster Civic Society leaflet 45

Tidal roads

There are two roads in the Lancaster area that are tidal – the B5273 from Oxcliffe to Middleton and Overton, and the C road from Overton to Sunderland Point. They both follow closely the right (west) bank of the River Lune as it heads out into the Irish Sea. In places, the roads cross saltmarshes whose creeks are flooded at most high tides and even the marsh surface at spring high tides.

The tidal range in the lower Lune is considerable for an estuary, reflecting the wide tidal range in Morecambe Bay. There are road signs warning drivers of the danger and when not to attempt to drive these roads.

Up to the nineteenth century the most important local tidal road was the regular stage-coach route directly cross Morecambe Bay from Lancaster to Ulverston. The modern round-the-Bay roads and railway have made this very dangerous, across-the-Bay route redundant. The route is still used today for cross-Bay walks led by the Queen’s Guide.

From Sunderland Point across the marshes

New roads to open up Morecambe

The development of Morecambe required now roads to service housing expansion and to ease access by car to the expanding eastern areas of the resort. One such road was Broadway, opened in 1923 and now part of the A589.

It was designed to impress. It runs in a very gentle curve to the seafront and is remarkably wide in the style of a boulevard – wide carriageways are flanked by broad, tree-lined verges and pavements, with the large, expensive houses well set back in their generous building plots.  It is as Modernist in its design as the Midland Hotel (1933).

At the road’s seaward end the Broadway Hotel opened in 1937 in a red-brick Deco style. It was demolished in 2014 to make way for flats. What is now Central Drive was opened in 1994 after the railway lands leading to Promenade station had became redundant. Retailing and car parking took over from the carriage sidings.

A new road to open up Heysham

In the same spirit of economic development is the Heysham-to-M6 Link Road, fully opened in 2016 after a lengthy period of strong local opposition. This runs around the north of Lancaster and connects the M6 directly with the previously opened Morecambe Road-to-Heysham road (A683) at the College of Further Education.  It affords excellent views over Lancaster and is notable for the major bridges across the River Lune, the Lancaster Canal and the West Coast Mainline Railway. It is hoped that its construction will lead to major commercial development in the Heysham Port area.

The medieval, pre-toll road/A6 route into Lancaster from the south (Burrow Road)

Before the A6

Before the current A6 was built in 1824, the main road south from Lancaster followed a higher route to the west of the A6 and West Coast Mainline Railway. It is today called Burrow Road and Highland Brow as it approaches Galgate. That this was a more important medieval road than most is shown by a greater width than would be needed just to service the farms and hamlets around.

A new nineteenth-century road

As commerce expanded in the nineteenth century, speedier roads were needed before the railway reached Lancaster in 1840.  The current A6 south to Preston was opened in 1824 by the Garstang and Heiring Syke Trust. This was a toll road, the tolls paying for the road’s construction and maintenance on a straighter, more level alignment than its predecessor, which allowed faster journeys.

The toll house at Toll Bar Crescent in Scotforth (see below, c.1890) is now the site of a petrol station. The principle of toll roads largely disappeared in twentieth-centry Britain although it has survived in parts of Europe, and has been used in the UK more recently for major bridges, tunnels and the M6 Toll Road around Birmingham.

Toll Bar, south Lancaster. (Lancashire CC Lantern)

After the A6 came the M6

When the A6 had became inadequate for the national north-south road traffic – Lancaster was a notorious bottleneck in the 1930s – what is now the M6 was built, planned by Lancashire County in the interwar period. The first section was around Preston and opened in December 1958, followed by the section bypassing Lancaster (now Junctions 33 to 35) in April 1960.  It was the UK’s third stretch of motorway, the London to Birmingham M1 having opened in November 1959. The most impressive structure was the 400-feet (120-metres) bridge over the River Lune. At its centre is a graceful single arch of 230 ft (69m) built in two parallel sections of reinforced concrete. Junction 34, near the bridge, was built to a less-than-normal specification and has been rebuilt.

A road not to drive along

Technically Nip Hill, in central Lancaster between China Street and St Mary’s Parade, is still a road.  But it is so narrow, cobbled, twisting and steep that one really should not drive along it, though no notices prohibiting this are visible. It is a survivor from the many alleys and ginnels for handcarts and pedestrians that characterised medieval Lancaster.

Nip Hill, Lancaster

Roads worth driving along

Finally, some roads you should drive, just for their scenic value.

  • The roads along the Lune Valley, on either the south side (the A683) or the quieter north side.
  • Many of the roads around Silverdale and Arnside.
  • Littledale Road, from Little Fell Road (east of Lancaster) to Caton.

Private roads

The Haverbreaks estate in Lancaster is an example of an area where the houses are serviced by a private road – that is, one not maintained by the local council but by the residents who pay for its upkeep through their Residents Association. Other examples include The Grove in Bowerham and Eden Park in Scotforth. 

Text – Gordon Clark. Photographs – Gordon Clark unless otherwise acknowledged.

Header photo – Ian Greene

Published by Lancaster Civic Society (©2015; revised 2020).

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over eighty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

The first event for the new season started on Wednesday 13th with Andrew Reilly from Lancaster District Heritage Group giving his new presentation ‘Railways around Lancaster & Morecambe and a recording can now be viewed on our Recordings page.

Our next event is on 8th December 2021 – Nigel Neil – ‘Record it Before it Moves!’ Lessons learned from 35 years of recording buildings in advance of conversion – meeting starts at 7:30 pm.

Nigel’s interest in archaeology began when he was 10, when his parents took him to visit the Roman city of Ampurias on the Costa Brava. They said that they “didn’t think he had the aptitude” (aka wasn’t bright enough !) to follow them into a career in medicine, and didn’t mind that there was no (financial) future in the past. He did a degree in archaeology at Edinburgh (1977) and a Master of Science in Environmental Assessment at Liverpool (1993), which he did part time while living in Salford and working at Lancaster University. 

Meetings are by Zoom on the second Wednesday of each month starting at 7:30 pm and to see our other speakers, or if you wish to join a meeting, go to our Events Calendar page.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page

Share this:

Man who guided people across Morecambe Bay for 56 years dies aged 88

Cedric Robinson, who was longest-serving Queen’s Guide to the Sands, steered hundreds of thousands of people across sands

Helen Pidd North of England Editor – The Guardian, 20th November 2021

Cedric Robinson has led walkers across Morecambe Bay for 56 years as Queen’s Guide to the Sands. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

Cedric Robinson has led walkers across Morecambe Bay for 56 years as Queen’s Guide to the Sands. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

A man who for 56 years guided walkers across the treacherous sands of Morecambe Bay has died aged 88.

Cedric Robinson was the longest-serving Queen’s Guide to the Sands, a job created in 1548 during the dissolution of the monasteries, when the reigning monarch inherited an obligation to appoint guides for travellers over the sands of the bay.

For a salary of £15 a year, he steered hundreds of thousands of people away from the quicksands and fast-filling channels of the ever-changing bay, including Prince Phillip and Victoria Wood.

In a tribute, the Guide over Sands Trust said “now Cedric, it is time to rest your sandy feet”.

Born into a cockle-fishing family in the village of Flookburgh, near Grange-over-Sands, Robinson knew the sands like no other. He would lead huge groups of walkers across the bay in bare feet, his jeans and shirt sleeves rolled up and a staff in his hand, making sure his guests crossed safely, usually from Arnside to Kents Bank.

He was forced into a reluctant retirement in 2019 after struggling to recover from two hernia operations, guiding walkers in his tractor in his later years. “I thought I could go on for ever. My dad lived until he was 103,” Robinson told the Guardian then, clearly not quite at peace with the idea of hanging up the whistle he used to stop walkers going off course. “I always thought the day I retire would be the worst day of my life.”

In 1963 Robinson and his wife, Olive, moved into Guides Farm, a ramshackle cottage right on the coast in Kents Bank which comes with the job. In the early years they had no electricity or running water and even in recent years an open fire was their main source of heating. They were allowed to stay after his retirement, and Olive died there in August, aged 96.

Robinson loved the celebrity aspect of the job and never tired of regaling visitors with his more unusual crossings. Most traversed the bay on foot – though Prince Philip used a horse-drawn carriage.

Cedric Robinson guided Prince Philip across the bay in 1985 – Photo Getty Images

His voice would drop when he talked of the Bay’s darkest hour, when 23 Chinese cockle pickers died in 2004.

If someone proposed an idea that tickled Robinson, he usually gave it a go. Once he crossed with 27 geese as a fundraising stunt for an arthritis sufferer. On another occasion he hid in the bay from Anneka Rice for an episode of Treasure Hunt (“I was wondering if the helicopter and crew were ever going to find us, but eventually they did,” he recalled in one of the many volumes of his memoirs). Once he took Rick Stein out fishing for flounder. The TV chef said the flounder were “equally as good as fresh halibut”, Robinson remembered proudly in 2019.

Earlier this year he joined his successor, Michael Wilson, guiding a group of naturists across the bay. “When we asked if he was getting out of his tractor he simply replied, ‘no, I have the best view from up here!’” remembered Wilson on Saturday.

A family spokesman said: “He pioneered fundraising cross-bay walks and was responsible for leading 6,000 charity walkers a year, avoiding the treacherous quicksands and dangerous areas.”

In a statement, Wilson and other marshals from the Guide Over Sands Trust said: “It is with great sadness that we write this post. Last night at the grand age of 88 our beloved Cedric Robinson closed his eyes for the last time, Cedric is now at peace and is with his wife Olive who he missed so much.

“Cedric had a huge following and we know that this news will make the community shed a tear upon reading this.

“Cedric joined us this year out on the sand – even though he had retired he kept going all he could. Now Cedric it is time to rest your sandy feet and keep an eye on us from up there.”

Weekend Walk (New) – Hospitals in Lancaster and Morecambe

Among the more important buildings in the local area have been its hospitals.  This leaflet tells you more about them.

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet No. 83

The Leper Hospital

This is the first hospital we know of in the Lancaster area. It was solely for lepers and was more a hospice than a hospital in the modern sense. Treatments to alleviate or cure this serious and feared disease were very limited. The Leper Hospital was situated outside Lancaster, deliberately isolated, roughly where St Leonard’s Gate meets Bulk Road, near Factory Hill and Hinde Street. Little survives of it. It is believed to have been founded by John, Earl of Mortain in the early 1190s and it was operational for around 300 years until the early 1500s when it fell into disuse and was demolished. The Hospital was supported by income from a nearby corn mill and farmland. The site comprised Spittel House where the lepers lived, a chapel and perhaps a warden’s house.        

The location of the Leper Hospital (Source: Ordnance Survey 6-inch map, surveyed in 1844/5

The Dispensaries

Before Lancaster had a hospital, it had a Dispensary.  This provided care for wounds and those basic treatments for illnesses thought efficacious at the time. Public subscriptions paid for some care for the very poor. Over time, Lancaster’s dispensary operated from three locations. The first was on Castle Hill (its photograph below) which was in operation between 1781 and 1785. The building was demolished in 1906 to make way for the expansion of the Storey Institute (see Leaflet No. 68 in this series).

The second location was used between 1785 and 1833 and was at 19 Castle Hill. It was purpose-built as a dispensary by public subscription and the building still stands today. The third location, used between 1833 and 1906, was at 6 Thurnham Street on its corner with George Street. The building dates from around 1800 and was converted to medical use. The northern part survives as Owen House, the southern part having been demolished around 1900 and it is now the Royal Hotel. It merged in 1832/3 with the House of Recovery which had been established in 1815 on Plumb Street off Bulk Street. This has been demolished and is now a car park.

A Coade stone image of the Good Samaritan has been a part of each of the Dispensaries and is now to be found above the entrance to Medical Unit 1 of the Royal Lancaster Infirmary.

The first Dispensary, Castle Park (Source: Red Rose Collection, Lancashire County Council,
gratefully acknowledged)
The second Dispensary, 19 Castle Hill (Source: Author)
The Third Dispensary, 6 Thurnham Street (Source: Lancaster City Museum, gratefully acknowledged)

Sanatoria and Isolation / Infectious Disease Hospitals

Whereas the Dispensary was always conveniently near the centre of Lancaster, the prevalence of infectious diseases in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries prompted the building of hospitals well outside the built-up areas to protect the healthy from infection and to cater for those with tuberculosis whose treatment required the clean air of the countryside. These diseases included tuberculosis, smallpox, diphtheria and scarlet fever.

The first to be built was the Luneside Hospital in 1880 off New Quay Road. It was closed in the very early 1890s and the site was taken over by Williamson’s for an extension to their Lune Mills. These too have been demolished and the hospital’s site is now housing on Nairn Road.

The Infectious Diseases Hospital for Lancaster in 1891 just before it closed. (Source: Ordnance Survey 6-inch map surveyed in 1891, gratefully acknowledged)

In 1885 a unit for infectious diseases was opened next to but separate from the Lancaster Workhouse on Quernmore Road. This catered for the Workhouse patients but also some from the town. It has been demolished and the site is now part of Lancaster Royal Grammar School.

The role of Luneside Hospital (see above) was taken over by Lancaster Sanatorium at Marsh Point further west down the River Lune. This opened in 1891 and despite the flooding in 1907 and 1927 it remained open until 1934 when its role was taken over by Beaumont Hospital (see below). There were three main buildings for the infectious cases and the staff, huts in the grounds for tuberculosis patients and there was also a small smallpox unit on the south-west edge of the site. Until recently the site has been a depot for a builders merchant. By 2021 only the middle of the three original sanatorium blocks remains.

Lancaster Isolation Hospital (Source: Ordnance Survey 6-inch map surveyed in 1931, gratefully acknowledged)

In 1895 a very small unit for smallpox cases was opened on Little Fell Lane. The buildings are now private houses.

Similar developments were taking place in Morecambe at about the same time. By 1889 a small, infectious-diseases hospital had been opened for Morecambe on open fields set back from, and north of Lancaster Road, roughly where Lathom Avenue is. Nothing remains of the buildings, which burned down in 1900, and the area has been suburban housing for many decades.

The 1911 OS map shows its much larger replacement just west of Torrisholme Barrow.

Morecambe Sanatorium (Source: Ordnance Survey 6-inch map surveyed in 1931,
gratefully acknowledged)

In the Lune Valley Lunesdale Rural District Council developed its own isolation hospital south of Farleton, high above the River Lune. It opened in 1891, closed in 1934 and was demolished in 1938.

The role of all these sanatoria and isolation and infectious-diseases hospitals was taken over in 1934 by the new Beaumont Hospital on Slyne Road. It was built in an Art Deco style and after infectious diseases became rarer and more treatable it took on other medical specialities. It closed in 1990 and was demolished to make way for Beaumont Park housing estate.

Beaumont Hospital (Source: National Archives, gratefully acknowledged)

The hospitals

As the nineteenth century progressed, it became increasingly clear that the Dispensary on Thurnham Street was becoming unfit for purpose. It was a house, albeit a large one, that had been converted to medical uses. The rooms were too small and their layout unhelpful. Developments in medicine during the century required not only more space but also different sorts of specialist space, especially for the expanding field of surgery. The Thurnham Street site was becoming landlocked preventing its expansion: a new hospital on a new site was needed.

 Discussions about a new hospital began in the 1880s and initial plans were drawn up in 1889. The foundation stone was laid in 1893 and the Royal Lancaster Infirmary opened in 1896. It was designed by the Lancaster firm of architects Paley, Austin and Paley, and possibly by E G Paley, the senior partner. Today this is Medical Unit 1 on the northern side of the current hospital site.

Royal Lancaster Infirmary soon after its opening (Source: https://historic-hospitals.com)

Subsequently the hospital was extended in 1929 and 1934 and more recently by Medical Unit 2 on the west side, the Women’s Unit and the Centenary Building, the latter designed by Tom Mellor and Partners and opened in 1996. As you enter Medical Unit 1, passing the Good Samaritan carving above the doorway, you see in the lobby the wooden boards commemorating the donors who paid for the new hospital and its running costs.  One of the most generous was James Williamson who laid the foundation stone.

In Morecambe the foundation stone for the Queen Victoria Cottage Hospital was laid in 1900 and it opened in 1902. Again there were periodic extensions (1912, 1923, 1932 and a Nurses Home in 1934). The original building was demolished in 2002 and replaced by the current one. The building that was the Nurses Home remains as private accommodation.

By 1938 several community clinics had been set up in the Lancaster area – three for child welfare and two for maternity.

There were also medical facilities at the Royal Albert Hospital and Lancaster Moor Hospital – see Leaflets 73 and 74 in this series.

BMI The Lancaster Hospital on Meadowside is a private hospital established in the late 1970s converting the research unit of Storeys to medical uses.

Acknowledgement

Several sources have been used for this leaflet but the author would like to acknowledge particularly the online publications by the staff of Lancaster City Museum.

Text – Gordon Clark. Published by Lancaster Civic Society (©2021). www.lancastercivicsociety.uk.

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over eighty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

The first event for the new season started on Wednesday 13th with Andrew Reilly from Lancaster District Heritage Group giving his new presentation ‘Railways around Lancaster & Morecambe and a recording can now be viewed on our Recordings page.

Our next event is on 8th December 2021 – Nigel Neil – ‘Record it Before it Moves!’ Lessons learned from 35 years of recording buildings in advance of conversion – meeting starts at 7:30 pm.

Nigel’s interest in archaeology began when he was 10, when his parents took him to visit the Roman city of Ampurias on the Costa Brava. They said that they “didn’t think he had the aptitude” (aka wasn’t bright enough !) to follow them into a career in medicine, and didn’t mind that there was no (financial) future in the past. He did a degree in archaeology at Edinburgh (1977) and a Master of Science in Environmental Assessment at Liverpool (1993), which he did part time while living in Salford and working at Lancaster University. 

Meetings are by Zoom on the second Wednesday of each month starting at 7:30 pm and to see our other speakers, or if you wish to join a meeting, go to our Events Calendar page.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page

Wednesday Walk – St George’s Quay, Lancaster

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet 59

Lancaster as a port has always been difficult for mariners. The voyage up the River Lune from the Irish Sea involves many changes of course to follow the narrow and shifting deepest channel, with fast tidal flows and winds from any direction threatening to push you off course.

Figure 1 St George’s Quay, Lancaster

Additionally the river level can vary markedly with the big tidal ranges in Morecambe Bay. The amount of river water also varies depending on the rainfall in the river’s upland catchment area. Around 1680, an attempt to create an outport at Sunderland Point, much nearer the river mouth, was only partly successful given the costly need to horse-and-cart all the goods across tidal tracks the 8 miles (13 km) to Lancaster.

 Before 1750 there was another problem for merchants once the ships had reached Lancaster, their upstream passage being limited by the medieval bridge shown in Figure 2. Unless the river level was high, ships would have to anchor mid-stream and discharge their cargo into small boats to be rowed to the river bank.

Alternatively the ships could get closer to the land and rest on the riverbed for unloading, waiting to refloat at the next high tide. Moreover there was nowhere secure from the weather and theft to store the goods until they were needed.

With Sunderland Point an expensive option and the town’s facilities limited and slow, the Act of Parliament of 1749 allowing a quay to be built was an obvious improvement, as other ports, notably Liverpool, had already found.

The wealthy merchants formed the Lancaster Port Commission and the building of the quay was completed in the 1750s. Plots of land alongside the quay were sold off in 1751 and 1781 on which merchants rapidly built the warehouses shown on Mackreth’s map (Figure 2) and still standing today (Figures 1 and 3).

Figure 2 St George’s Quay as depicted on Stephen Mackreth’s map of Lancaster published in 1778

The traffic through the port and in the warehouses would reflect the Georgian-era industries and needs of the town of Lancaster – tropical woods for Gillow the furniture maker and sugar for the local refinery, alongside more local trade in cloth, wool, fish, building stone and manufactures (Figure 3).

As trade grew a second quay (New Quay) was built in 1768 just downstream that allowed for larger ships to call. This was useful when the land nearby later became industrialised. Soon after, a pier (1781–2) and wet dock (1787) were built at Glasson near the river mouth.

For bulky commodities such as coal and limestone there was some local competition from the Lancaster Canal when it opened in 1797 and in the subsequent decades when it attracted many mills to its banks. There are separate leaflets in this series on Sunderland Point, Glasson and the town’s canalside mills.

However, port traffic started to drift away from Lancaster itself, and Heysham Harbour opened in 1904. Goods landed at larger docks such as Preston, Liverpool and Manchester could be brought to Lancaster by train after the railway reached Lancaster from the south in 1840.

Figure 3 Former warehouses on St George’s Quay, Lancaster

The most impressive building on the Quay is the Custom House, which was completed in 1764. It was designed by Richard Gillow and provided a place for customs dues to be paid and for mariners to meet. Today it is the city’s Maritime Museum (Figure 4).   

Figure 4 Custom House, St George’s Quay, Lancaster

As port traffic declined, other users moved in. The area became run down and ‘rough’. The warehouses lacked maintenance and it showed. Some became empty and derelict.

From around 1970 architectural revival and social gentrification began to accelerate. Warehouses became flats, the poorest buildings at the quay’s west end were demolished and replaced by blocks of flats that respected the warehouse style of the neighbouring buildings.

Eateries and offices moved in. Figures 1 and 3 show the quay’s frontage in 2020.

Reading

A White (ed.) A History of Lancaster 1193–1993. Keele: Ryburn University Press. Chapter 3

Text and photographs – Gordon Clark

Header Photo – Ian Greene

Published by Lancaster Civic Society (©2020)

Property developers celebrate green light for £40m industrial scheme in Lancaster

Hurstwood Holdings has been granted full detailed planning permission to build a further 200,000 sq ft of speculative industrial space at Lune Business Park in Lancaster.

by Gayle Rouncivell Lancaster Guardian – 15th November 2021

How part of the site is expected to look

The £40m scheme will also include a new on-site café, pharmacy, convenience store and a nursery.

Hurstwood Holdings acquired Lune Business Park more than 15 years ago and has successfully managed the established scheme since.

Lune has proven to be popular with existing tenants such as First Subsea, which recently expanded its presence at the Park taking a total of 32,000 sq ft.

How part of the site is expected to look

The new scheme will offer floorplates from 1,000 sq ft up to 100,000 sq ft with design and build opportunities also available.

As part of the plans, Hurstwood will also be contributing to a new bus service connecting the business park to Lancaster city centre and surrounding areas.

Sam Ashworth, project director at Hurstwood Holdings, said: “This planning permission has been a long time coming and we are pleased to have finally secured this important milestone. Hurstwood owns two large industrial estates in Lancaster – Lune and Lansil – and we are fully committed to maximising the potential of these estates, which will bring significant economic benefits to area and further job creation.

“With continued cooperation of Lancaster City Council, we plan to start the first phase on site by the first quarter of 2022.”

The new scheme will be developed in phases over the next four years and Hurstwood will appoint a contractor in the coming weeks.

Based in Manchester, Hurstwood Holdings is a commercial investment group with more than £200m of commercial and residential assets on 120 sites nationwide housing more than 1,000 occupier clients.

Remembrance Sunday 2021

On 10th November Shaun Corkerry MA gave a fascinating presentation to Lancaster Civic Society members ‘A Country Village at War – the contribution of Galgate and Ellel Parish to the two World Wars’

Clearly, the subject was very topical being the day before 11th November and in the week running up to Remembrance Sunday.

Whilst the title refers particularly to the two wars it was both a social and military history of the then, at the time of the Great War, hamlet of only around six hundred people.

Shaun describes what the area was like during that time, what it was like during the two World Wars and where you can find further information.

It was interesting to note that during the Great War a small area such as Galgate and Ellel managed to send as many as two hundred people to serve out of a population of six hundred – there were many gallantry awards in both wars including  a Distinguished Service Medal, a Distinguished Flying Medal, an Air Force Medal, three Military Medals and two Mention in Despatches..

In Shaun’s presentation we meet, amongst others, Corporal Frank Jackson who was one of those who did not return from the Great War and who is commemorated on the Ellel War Memorial at St John’s Church, Galgate.

Corporal Frank Jackson
Newspaper report of the death of Corporal Frank Jackson

The full video of Shaun’s presentation can be viewed at:

Presentation given to Lancaster Civic Society Members 10th November 2021

There will be a Remembrance Service at St John’s Church, Galgate on Sunday 14th November

If you would like to learn more about the men and women of Galgate and Ellel that served in the two World Wars, and others, Shaun has written four books on the subject which are detailed below together with his contact details, as well as details of the Ellel War Memorial booklet which is available from St John’s Church.

Weekend Walk – Dolphinholme

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet No. 82

Dolphinholme is a village 9 km south-east of Lancaster on the River Wyre. The part of the village north of the river is on the edge of Lancaster City Council’s area: the southern part is in Wyre Council.

The area’s development from a hamlet comprising a farm and some cottages came when in 1784 a corn mill on the river was converted by three Lancaster merchants to the world’s first, fully automated spinning mill for worsted (a high quality woollen yarn), using Arkwright frames. The Wyre is prone to flooding and after two floods the original mill was rebuilt in 1795 further away from the river.

The mill obtained the power for its very large water-wheel from a mill race, which took water from a weir upstream.  A wool-combing mill and two warehouses were also built. A house for the mill’s manager (later a co-owner) was built at 2 Waggon (now Wagon) Road (Derham House).

The then mill owner, Thomas Hinde, lived close by in Old Mill House built around 1800. Hinde also owned mills in Lancaster and came from a family of traders and merchants.

Despite some workers walking daily to and from Forton to the Mill, there was a need to provide housing for the many more millworkers than the local area could provide and so the two rows of Corless Cottages were built in 1796. ‘Waggon Road’ going eastwards indicates that the yarn was taken to the Bradford area for weaving into worsted cloth.

The mill was extended in 1818.

Dolphinholme as shown on the Ordnance Survey 6-inch map surveyed in 1844
Part of Corless Cottages, Dolphinholme (Source: Author)

There was a gas works supplying the mill: it was built in 1811 and probably replaced in 1818. The gas was stored in a gasometer (gas holder), which was replaced in 1820. The associated chimney stack also survives, at a distance to obtain a better draught.

The remains of the gasworks were designated a Scheduled Monument in 2020 because they comprise probably the earliest gas plant for a mill known to survive in the world. Many of the work’s components are still visible for study.

Dolphinholme was one of the very earliest mills to be lit at night by gas, a major saving in candles and reducing the fire danger. In 1811 Dolphinholme was one of the first places in Britain to have street lighting using gas.

In 1822 a steam engine was installed to deal with low water levels in the Wyre and keep the machines working. Today the former mill site is private property.

The Chapel of Ease shown on the above map was built in 1839–40 and was replaced in 1897–8 by the current Church of St Mark and its vicarage, which were designed by the Lancaster architects, Paley and Austin. The church’s roof beams and window tracery are worth seeing. There were also Congregational and Wesleyan Methodist chapels.

The bridge across the Wyre was constructed in 1791. The original school was built in 1865. Taken as a whole, Dolpinholme is a very good example of a mill community.

St Mark’s Church, Dolphinholme (Source: Author)

Mills are vulnerable to poor management and economic depressions and Dolphinholme mill is no exception. Hinde’s firm collapsed with huge debts in 1839 due to problems with their Yorkshire enterprises and a slump in trade.

The mill was taken over by the Swainsons who carried on spinning worsted. In 1852/3 Henry Rushton converted the mill to cotton spinning. In 1867 the mill closed and was demolished between 1890 and 1910 – too small, old and isolated from the core of the British textile trades to be competitive.

Old MIll House and Woodcock Hall, Dolphinholme (Source: Author)

Just south of Dolphinholme is Wyresdale Hall (see below) Grade II listed.

After 1790 the intention was for this old hall to be remodelled according to a plan by Robert Adam for James Fenton Cawthorne (later to become MP for Lancaster). However, this was not completed and in 1843/44 the house was redesigned in a Neo-Classical style by Edmund Sharpe, the Lancaster architect, for Robert Garnett who had bought the house in 1836. The Garnetts were major local landowners.

There were later additions to the Hall in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries and the building is now private apartments. There is an icehouse in the grounds.

Wyresdale Hall in the 1890s (Source: Red Rose Collection, Lancashire County Council, gratefully acknowledged)

Today, much of Dolphinholme is a Conservation Area with 16 listed buildings including the bridge (1791), all Grade II. The Castle Hill Motte is a Schedule Monument, being the remnants of a Norman Castle erected to control movement along the River Wyre.

Dolphinholme is a thriving community with its shop, primary school, village hall and inn, and new housing estates.

The River Wyre from Dolphinholme Bridge (Source: Author)

Reading

Winstanley, M (ed.) (2000) Rural Industries of the Lune Valley. Lancaster: Lancaster University: Centre for North-West Regional Studies

Edmund Sharpe: Lancaster’s  Renaissance Man. Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet  No. 32.

Historic England  Remains of the gas plant, chimney, wheel pit and mill race of Dolphinholme Worsted Mill, Nether Wyresdale – 1466557 | Historic England

Lancaster City Council Conservation Area Appraisals (Dolphinholme) 2016 Conservation area appraisals – Lancaster City Council

Text – Gordon Clark. Published by Lancaster Civic Society (©2021).

www.lancastercivicsociety.uk.

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over eighty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

The first event for the new season started on Wednesday 13th with Andrew Reilly from Lancaster District Heritage Group giving his new presentation ‘Railways around Lancaster & Morecambe and a recording can now be viewed on our Recordings page.

Our next event is on 8th December 2021 – Nigel Neil – ‘Record it Before it Moves!’ Lessons learned from 35 years of recording buildings in advance of conversion – meeting starts at 7:30 pm.

Nigel’s interest in archaeology began when he was 10, when his parents took him to visit the Roman city of Ampurias on the Costa Brava. They said that they “didn’t think he had the aptitude” (aka wasn’t bright enough !) to follow them into a career in medicine, and didn’t mind that there was no (financial) future in the past. He did a degree in archaeology at Edinburgh (1977) and a Master of Science in Environmental Assessment at Liverpool (1993), which he did part time while living in Salford and working at Lancaster University. 

Meetings are by Zoom on the second Wednesday of each month starting at 7:30 pm and to see our other speakers, or if you wish to join a meeting, go to our Events Calendar page.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page