Lancaster Civic Vision (LCV) welcomed the publication of the Canal Quarter Strategic Regeneration Framework and Supplementary Planning Document [SPD].
Source Canal Quarter SPD November 2021 – Lancaster City Council
LCV were encouraged by the scale and ambition articulated and reassured by the commitment to protect and build upon the existing heritage, townscape, and landscape assets of the area. They are also impressed by the depth of analysis underpinning the proposals and are pleased to see a commitment to the highest standards of design and energy efficiency.
Terraced landscape adjacent to canal at Granary Square, London – source Canal Quarter Masterplan Lancaster City Council
They now welcome and generally support the emerging Masterplan and the four design principles it is based upon.
However, Civic Vision remain concerned about the lack of specificity or commitment to the provision of social housing within the Canal Quarter Masterplan. The need for more social housing was evidenced in the recent Homes Strategy which highlighted that “in excess of 6,000 households in the district require affordable housing.”
The Masterplan highlights the St. Leonards Gate area as a site for new housing and states that the Housing Team are currently developing options for the area and continues that the options explored incorporate the latest comments from members engagement. Six points are listed all of which relate to house type, massing, scale, and landscaping etc. No mention is made of housing tenure!
We find this particularly disappointing as Lancaster Civic Vision has consistently raised the issue of social housing in previous Canal Quarter consultation exercises.
The Council in its response to comments on the SPD stated:
“As a policy document intended for third parties, as well as informing the city council’s approach to its own landholdings the SPD is informed by all other relevant policies in the Local Plan, particularly those concerning the minimum % of affordable accommodation in housing proposals.
The final approach to housing in implementation will be heavily influenced by the city council’s own housing objectives as owner of a large proportion of the land highlighted in the SPD for housing, balanced against the practical concerns of development viability. Further consideration will need to be given to tenure and type of housing able to be delivered and the SPD will assist in informing these discussions”
LCV questions why the Masterplan is silent on any consideration of housing tenure?
Well designed cycle storage with a green roof at Birmingham Conservatoire – source Canal Quarter Masterplan Lancaster City Council
Civic Vision have consistently made the point that this is a missed opportunity for the City Council to begin to deliver on its commitment to the socially just use of land and property.
We are also concerned that the views of the Council’s Housing Advisory Group [HAG] do not appear to have been considered during the preparation of the Canal Quarter Masterplan. At a meeting of the HAG held on 8th July 2021 the following recommendation was agreed:
“On the 6th August 2019 the City Council Cabinet agreed the principle of embedding of the five Community Wealth Building Principles within LCC and across the district” The fourth of these principles is stated as “Socially just use of land and property”. The Housing Advisory Group should formally request that the City Council in line with this policy commitment should:
Consider supporting the establishment of a further Community Led Housing Initiative.
Identify a council owned site within the Canal Quarter to facilitate the development of a Community Led Housing Initiative”
It was understood that this recommendation would be considered by City Council. LCV are therefore disappointed that this recommendation appears to have been ignored in preparation of the Masterplan.
Civic Vision would also argue that not only should the Housing Team be developing options for the St. Leonards Gate area but that they should lead on the implementation of this development.
LCV are also surprised that no mention is made of the potential role of the Councils Housing Company in facilitating social housing within the Canal Quarter.
Morehomes for the Bay, incorporated in June 2021 was established with the aim of allowing the Council to deliver a wider range of good quality affordable housing.
The Council argued that through this it will benefit from greater flexibility and legal freedoms to do more for its communities and help maximise borrowing options and capital finance to deliver new housing schemes.
LCV understood that this would include the provision of new homes for social rental, private rent and for purchase by owner-occupiers. It is therefore puzzling that the Masterplan makes no mention of the potential role of Morehomes for the Bay in advancing the Council’s ambitions for the Canal Quarter.
Civic Vision would suggest that Lancaster residents who are also concerned by this omission of Social Housing from the Canal Quarter Masterplan should raise this question with their local Councillor and/or the City Council at keepconnected
Whilst looking at Morecambe’s Magnificent Buildings we should not forget the piers.
‘The Pier’ opened in March 1869 which then became ‘Central Pier’ when the West End Pier opened in 1896.
Piers at that time were seen as a way of adding additional attractions along the sea front where prime sites were already taken and there were around two hundred dotted about the UK coast line. They were extremely popular with holidaymakers and Central Pier had capacity for 2,000 dancers in the 1930s.
A short film by Mitchel & Kenyon shows West End Pier as very much a centre where it was fashionable to be seen in 1901.
A printable version of this guide can be downloaded at the bottom of this page
Morecambe’s Piers
Lancaster Civic Vision Guide 81
The pier, though not uniquely British, has been a distinctive feature of many seaside resorts since the mid-nineteenth century. By ‘pier’ we mean a jetty built out to sea that is used principally for leisure purposes and probably was constructed specifically for them. A pier may also be used for leisure boating. This distinguishes a pier from a jetty used for goods traffic at a harbour.
The National Pier Society suggests that there are around 60 piers still on the British coastline and around 40 former piers that have been lost. The pier at Ryde (Isle of Wight) was the first in 1814 and Southend pier (then and now the longest) was the second in 1830.
The first in North-West England was Southport pier, which opened in 1860. The 1860s was a major period of pier building – 22 in Great Britain – with Blackpool North in 1863, Lytham in 1865, New Brighton in 1867 and Blackpool Central in 1868. The General Pier and Harbour Act of 1861 helped the developers of piers.
Morecambe’s first pier was mooted in 1867, building began in 1868 and it opened on 25 March 1869. Until 1914 steamers could tie up at the seaward end. ‘The Pier’ became ‘Central Pier’ when the ‘West End Pier’ opened in 1896.
With the railways delivering ever-increasing numbers of summer visitors – often packed into the different Wakes Weeks of the northern mill towns – the race was on to provide the visitors with more entertainment in the resort. The prime sites with the largest footfall along the sea front were already in use, therefore building a pier out to sea with entertainment venues built on top of it was an attractive commercial prospect.
The shallower the sea out from the shore, the cheaper to build and the longer the pier could be, with more space for revenue-generating venues. Moreover, if rival resorts were building piers your resort had to keep up, and so Morecambe followed the lead of Southport, Blackpool and Lytham.
Central Pier Pavilion, early 1900s (Source: Red Rose Collection, Lancashire County Council, gratefully acknowledged)
West End Pier, early 1900s (Source: Red Rose Collection, Lancashire County Council, gratefully acknowledged)
West End Pier, early 1900s (Source: Red Rose Collection, Lancashire County Council, gratefully acknowledged)
The commercial imperative of a pier rested on two features – minimising construction costs and maximising the income from visitors. Very many Victorian piers were built similarly – cast-iron legs and wrought-iron bracing topped by a wooden deck with a broader area, often at the seaward end, for a major entertainment building (a ‘pavilion’).
Central Pier was actually bought second-hand after having lain in Liverpool Docks for two years because it had been rejected by its original purchaser in Valparaiso, Chile. It was a good deal for the pier company, reducing their costs greatly.
Maximising revenue, in competition with the land-side theatres and halls, meant getting as many paying customers onto the pier for as long as possible and as often as possible. The entry fee to the pier – to generate income and keep out the unruly – admitted you to a world of lavish, even exotic decoration (it was nicknamed the ‘Taj Mahal’ on Central Pier), stalls and shops, and places to eat and drink run by the pier owner or leased to others.
The entertainment venue had to cater for tastes throughout the day and evening – shows for the children; the comics, acrobats, singers and magicians of the musical hall; the theatre- and concert-goers; and above all those who wanted to dance.
Central Pier had capacity for 2000 dancers in the 1930s and facilities for roller skating. The piers provided whatever was popular at the time, which evolved. You could attract more visitors if you booked bigger-name entertainers than rival resorts, for the whole summer season or for a shorter run.
The piers were so commercially successful that they were extended – Central Pier in 1871 and 1898, West End Pier in 1898. A short silent film by Mitchell and Kenyon shows West End Pier in 1901 and it is available here:
https://youtu.be/VzE3qgvI3JU
Morecambe’s West End Pier is a hive of high fashion in this lovely seaside snapshot by Edwardian film pioneers Mitchell & Kenyon. Genteel promenaders parade for the camera, showing off their grand outfits: men in top hats and boaters, women swathed in lace and a boy in a silk sailor suit.
Looked at sceptically, a pier was a fragile risky structure, exposed to winter storms and liable to accidental or deliberate fires given its many wooden elements.
Morecambe’s piers had a chequered history. West End Pier was breached in two places by a storm in 1903, damaged again in 1907, and the Pavilion was severely fire-damaged in 1917.
More damage was caused by a storm in 1927. Each time it was worth rebuilding and repairing the pier. Central Pier suffered a major fire at the seaward end in 1933. Again, a major rebuild was commercially justified, allowing more space for dancing and roller skating.
The fire on Central Pier in 1933 (Source: Red Rose Collection, Lancashire County Council, gratefully acknowledged)
Morecambe’s declining tourist trade after the late 1950s could no longer support the piers or justify their rebuilding when damaged. West End Pier suffered its final storm damage in 1977 and it was demolished in 1978. Decking on Central Pier collapsed in 1986 and it closed for good. Following fires in 1987 and 1991, it was demolished in 1992.
All that remains of the two piers is the tell-tale widening of the Promenade from where the piers projected into Morecambe Bay – near the Clock Tower for Central Pier and at the junction of the Promenade and Regent Road for West End Pier.
Details about the Stone Jetty can be found in Guide 13 in this series.
Reading
Bingham R K 1990 Lost Resort? The Flow and Ebb of Morecambe. Milnthorpe: Cicerone Press
Visitors and tourists first impressions of some our historic and listed buildings on their approach to the city is one of neglect, uncared for and in a few instances wilful destruction.
Listed buildings have in the past needed to be demolished in order to protect the public due to this kind of deliberate action, and these have been lost for ever against the will of the City and its residents.
Lancaster Civic Vision, which aims to monitor planning proposals currently under consideration, is becoming increasingly concerned about the number of prominent buildings, mostly under the ownership of local property developers, which are being neglected and allowed to fall into dereliction without realistic proposals being put forward to the City Council for their development.
The Alexandra – Grade ll Listed building – with its upper floors open to the elements after window removal – photo Andrew Reilly
The Alexandra Hall, an important listed building on Penny Street, has had all upper window frames removed and stands open to all weathers, with the fabric inevitably deteriorating.
No action has been taken since planning permission to convert it into an apart-hotel was refused over a year ago.
The Alexandra – Grade ll Listed building – with its upper floors open to the elements after window removal – photo Andrew Reilly
The Odd Fellows Hall in Brock Street, another listed building, has been allowed to deteriorate to such an extent that there must be serious concerns about the safely of the structure. Planning permission for the conversion of the building into student accommodation lapsed some years ago, but still there is no evidence of any proposed development for the site.
Odd Fellows Hall, Brock Street Grade ll listed building – photo Andrew Reilly
Elsewhere, in Bowerham, there is the continuing eyesore of the site of the Parkfield Garage which has been the subject of planning disputes over a number of years.
The Bowling Green pub, on the main A6 approach into Lancaster, is another prominently visible building which has lain unoccupied for some years, and is deteriorating rapidly, whilst no planning applications have yet been received by the City Council.
Odd Fellows Hall, Brock Street Grade ll listed building – photo Andrew Reilly
We are aware of the efforts of the Planning Department’s Enforcement Team in trying to engage with developers to take responsibility for their properties, but their resources and powers are sadly limited.
The old saying goes that ‘you never get a second chance to make a first impression’.
Is this the impression we want visitors and tourists to our City to take away with them?
Odd Fellows Hall, Brock Street Grade ll listed building – photo Andrew Reilly
Today the Mill Race comes off the River Lune at Dalton Dam near Skerton Weir and the former Wagon Works on Caton Road, and it now re-enters the Lune near Fleet Square at the eastern end of the former railway bridge from Green Ayre Station to Lancaster Castle Station. It is nearly 1500 yards long and in the eighteenth century was about 6 yards wide and between 1 foot 8 inches and 2 feet 8 inches deep.
During Storm Desmond in December 2015, the Mill Race, overwhelmed by the volume of rainwater in such a short time period flooded the lower part of Lancaster. This flooding had a devastating effect on the businesses that traded there.
Lancaster Civic Vision are currently working with Lancaster City Council to produce a heritage trail of the Mill Race – a circular walk around the original area – visiting over a dozen Heritage Plaques of important sites along the way and which we hope will be launched in November 2022.
At the end of this guide please view the excellent photos courtesy of Andrew Reilly, Lancaster Past & Present of the Mill Race and tunnels taken at the time of repair work undertaken by United Utilities and rebuilding in the city.
A printable version of this guide can be downloaded at the bottom of this page.
The Mill Race Lancaster
Lancaster Civic Vision Guide 79
When you look at a map of central Lancaster, one of the things that catches your eye is the long curved road comprising Parliament Street, North Road and Damside Street.
Its route indicates the line of the Mill Race, a channel off the River Lune that, before it was culverted, separated the higher parts of the town from the flat, low-lying land we now call the Green Ayre. An ‘ayre’ is a local word for an island, of which the lower Lune had and still has several, near Skerton and at Salt Ayre downstream, for example. Guide 84 gives more details about the islands.
The origin of the Mill Race is unclear. The most likely explanation is that it is a natural feature, one of many branches off the Lune – a ‘braided’ river – that create gravel and silt islands which change location and shape with the effects of floods and natural river meandering. Subsequently the main channel of the Lune moved northwards to its current line, leaving the Mill Race as a minor channel.
Today the Mill Race comes off the Lune at Dalton Dam near Skerton Weir and the former Wagon Works on Caton Road, and it now re-enters the Lune near Fleet Square at the eastern end of the former railway bridge from Green Ayre Station to Lancaster Castle Station. It is nearly 1500 yards long and in the eighteenth century was about 6 yards wide and between 1 foot 8 inches and 2 feet 8 inches deep.
The ‘Race’ part of its name seems an exaggeration. However, the ‘Mill’ part is correct because for centuries there was a corn mill roughly opposite where Caulkeld Lane joins Damside Street. It was demolished soon after 1769 and was one of several mills there have been along the Mill Race at various times.
Speed’s map of Lancaster, surveyed in 1607, showing the loop of the Mill Race and Green Ayre at the top. No. 9 on the map is “The Mill” and No. 1 is the “Green Ayre”.
The first map of Lancaster to show the Mill Race is John Speed’s, surveyed in 1607 (see above), which shows the Mill Race, the Mill and the Green Ayre, the latter then an open area. Apart from bridges at the Mill only two bridges crossed the Mill Race. By the time of Kuerden’s map of 1685 there were five bridges but the area remained largely undeveloped and it still was in the 1720s.
The Green Ayre was an area for bowls, exercising and racing horses (see Guide 78 on Lancaster’s race courses) and for taking exercise. Yet to some landowners the area was a potentially profitable development site for housing and industry, even though prone to flooding. Each development needed to cross the Mill Race, so bridges abounded. By 1754 13 bridges over the Mill Race had been marked on maps and four others are recorded in documents.
By the time of Mackreth’s map surveyed in the mid-1770s (see below), most of the western part of The Mill Race had been completely covered over by Damside Street, which was extended soon after 1769 to meet the Mill Race’s exit to the Lune.
The eastern part was partly covered and partly still open. Both the Mill Race’s entry and exit points were moved in the mid-nineteenth century to accommodate the sidings east of Green Ayre Station and the new railway bridge from Green Ayre westwards to Lancaster Castle Station.
The section east of what is now Bulk Road (formerly Germany Street) was wholly open alongside Ladies Walk until filled in at the time of the First World War.
As shown on Mackreth’s map surveyed in the mid-1770s, the road here called Dam Side (now North Road) has the Mill Race on its southern side (south is at the top of the map), partly bridged and built over and party still open. The Green Ayre is filling up with housing to the west, industrial uses and St John’s Chapel (now Church).
The Old Mill Race between the Rope Walk and the Ladies Walk, east of the town centre, as shown on Mackreth’s map surveyed in the nmid-1770s. South is at the top of this map.
So far the story of the Mill Race has been one of the progressive bridging over of this obstruction to accessing and developing the Green Ayre.
After 1812, the Mill Race acquired a new use – as the town’s largest sewer. It had always been tempting to dump rubbish and waste materials into this broad sluggish channel. But after 1812 central Lancaster acquired an expanding network of stone-lined sewers beneath the streets into which houses could empty their liquid wastes. These sewers also took away some of the rainwater.
The street sewers all led downhill to the town’s lowest point, the Mill Race and so to the River Lune, unless heavy rain and/or a high tide caused the Mill Race to back up into the leaky street sewers, people’s basements and their wells for drinking water. Richard Owen’s report in 1845 publicised the town’s very poor mortality record – particularly in the lowest-lying part of town – and therefore the need for a better sewage system.
In the 1850s an interceptor sewer was eventually built along the south side of the Mill Race, which emptied into the Lune. This normally kept the sewage securely separate from the Mill Race, though there could still be an overflow. The floor of the Mill Race was concreted over in 1890/1 and given a smoother gradient to improve its flow. Today the sewage is led along new pipes by the side of the Lune to the wastewater treatment works at Stodday, south of Lancaster.
The roads over or near the MiIl Race carry large numbers of vehicles every day and in 1998 major repairs to the Mill Race and the sewers were needed at the junction of Damside Street, North Road and Rosemary Lane. In the 2010s major works were carried out at several places along the Mill Race to construct very large, underground overflow tanks in central Lancaster to cope safely with major inflows of rainwater and prevent flooding in the town.
The map below shows the present-day relationship of Damside Street, the Mill Race and the buildings. Sometimes the Mill Race is south of the road: sometimes north of it; and often it now lies underneath the neighbouring buildings. The road works in 1998 mentioned above were where the road crossed the Mill Race.
Today it is hard to spot the Mill Race itself but it has left a clear imprint on this part of Lancaster.
The approximate alignment of the Mill Race today in relation to Damside Street, North Road and neighbouring buildings (Source: Lancaster City Council)
Reading
The main source for this leaflet is:
Horsfield K (2001) The Lancaster Mill Race with notes on the Green Ayre. Settle, North Yorkshire: Hudson History
Lancaster City Council (2021) Lancaster Highstreets Heritage Action Zone. Mill Race
Conservation Management Plan, Stage 1 (Draft). p95. Lancaster: Lancaster City Council
Lancaster Civic Vision is the trading name of Lancaster Civic Society, registered charity no. 258434
Lancaster Past & Present on Facebook has not only a history of the Mill Race but also a series of underground photographs, many taken during the repairs to damage caused during Storm Desmond in 2015, and when there have been redevelopments around the City.
Two more guides this weekend, both of which have had a very important role in the history of Lancaster but can no longer been seen – today St George’s Works on St George’s Quay – the first purpose built Hi-Rise structure and the first identifiable flat roofed factory anywhere – and tomorrow The Mill Race.
Both however are now the subject of new initiatives to retain our knowledge of the parts they have played in the development of modern Lancaster.
Lancaster Civic Vision will, later this month, be unveiling a Heritage Plaque near to the original site of St George’s Works and we are also working with Lancaster City Council to create and publish a Heritage Trail following the original path of the Mill Race and which we hope will be launched some time in November.
Both areas however, are well worthy of a visit after reading these guides, in order to try and visualise their impact on the areas at that time.
St George’s Works, St George’s Quay, Lancaster – 1854 – 2018
Constructed between 1854 and 1860 St George’s Works was the first purpose-built, High-Rise structure, of industrialist James Williamson senior and the first identifiable flat-roofed industrial building anywhere. It produced oilcloth for floor coverings, table cloths and blinds with the fabric being manufactured on the upper floors and passed through gaps in the floors to be hung and dried in the taller space of the ground floor.
Significance of the Building:
The Williamson’s Works stood here in the footprint of the present student resident block fronting the Quay below the Castle and Priory.
The building represented the historic remains of the huge oilcloth and lino industry which existed along the Quay until the latter part of the 20th Century. According to local historian James Price “This was by the 1890’s probably the largest industrial complex in the world, stretching from the Carlisle Bridge area down to and including parts of Freeman’s Wood”.
St George’s Works in its heyday c.1900 – Photo courtesy P.J. Gooderson (1996), Lord Linoleum: Lord Ashton, Lancaster and the Rise of the British Oilcloth and Linoleum Industry, Keele University
At this time the Williamson’s (father and son) factories accounted for about 1/3 of global linoleum and oilcloth production and 50% of world exports. The son, James, left the 4th largest estate in Britain between 1809 and the time of his death in 1930. The complex was served conveniently both by river and rail links.
Origins, Purpose and Structure of the Works:
The Works, constructed between 1854 and 1860 was the first purpose-built structure of industrialist James Williamson senior, who previously used an adapted malt kiln sited closer to Carlisle Bridge.
It produced oilcloth for floor coverings, table cloths and blinds. The fabric was manufactured on the upper floors and passed through gaps in the floors to be hung and dried in the taller space of the ground floor. The Works site, which expanded from the 1860’s, and also along the Quay at Lune Mills, produced its own varnish for finishing the fabric. It also included linseed oil processing facilities, and even a brickworks and rail connection
The railway embankment for this can still be seen along the area of the present housing development which adjoins Long Marsh Lane. This linked the Works to the main line at Lancaster Castle Station from which its products were despatched all over the world.
The Works Building – a Modern High – Rise Idea:
The building itself was designed by the surveyor Charles F. Thompson of Castle Hill, Lancaster who went on to plan several subsequent buildings for Williamsons. St George’s Works was an innovative building in many ways. It was the first identifiable flat-roofed industrial building anywhere.
The flat roof with the Carlisle Bridge rail line in the background – photo courtesy R.o.C. Consulting, 2016 Structural Survey Report on St. George’s Works
Secondly, it departed from existing building methods. Buildings at the time had flooring supported by brick arches resting on cast iron girders and columns, or sometimes girders supported by outer wall structures as with Shrewsbury Flax Mill. Railway bridges, and in the 1860’s, the newly rebuilt Houses of Parliament, depended on brick arches.
However the flooring of St George’s Works rested primarily on 12 inch deep steel, rather than cast iron girders – itself innovative at the time. These formed a lattice or grid with secondary or smaller cast iron girders. The girders were supported by cast iron columns linked to each other through the floors. The way these link the lattice of girders can be seen below.
Intersection of girders through cast iron pillars – photo courtesy R.o.C. Consulting, 2016 Structural Survey Report on St. George’s Works
From a different perspective – photo courtesy R.o.C. Consulting, 2016 Structural Survey Report on St. George’s Works
This arrangement provided a self-supporting integrated internal structure which was largely independent of the external walls and which provided a secondary load bearing support. The self-supporting internal structure idea was an unusual and possibly novel building technique at the time and is otherwise found in modern high rise buildings dating from the late 19th Century and early 20th Century Bauhaus period.
Other unique features were related to fire prevention – something which severely affected Williamson’s Lancaster competitors the Storey brothers. Williamson minimised fire damage by laying 2 ½ inch pine floorboards which were then covered by a screed of cement around 6 inches deep. This acted as an effective flame retardant and adjoining departments were also connected by metal fire doors – all ideas new in the mid 19th Century.
Decline and Demolition:
Following the decline in oilcloth and lino production the Works building was occupied by various businesses from the 1970’s. It was latterly unused and damaged by fire which, as following the building’s design, had more effect on the lattice of girders than the flooring itself.
The Works just prior to its demolition in 2018 – Photo Howard Feather, Lancaster Civic Vision
The Works was demolished in 2018 to be replaced by student flats which largely mirror the form of the original building and an adjoining housing estate which covers the original industrial site at George’s Quay.
The place where we live and/or work is in a state of constant change, but often it is not until we look at old images that we realise how great that change has been.
The Time Travel Artist has created two video montages:
Lancaster – A City Through Time an animated look at Lancaster then and now and reaching back nearly four hundred years
Lancaster Castle Through Time – 1728-2022 a look back at Lancaster Castle/ Prison through the centuries
Two totally different views of Lancaster this weekend. First a review of how different Lancaster looked during that period of ‘National Hibernation’ in 2020 during lockdown as presented by Andrew Reilly in two excellent videos that he created during that time.
Tomorrow we compare how both Lancaster and Lancaster Castle were in the past through two very fascinating videos created by The Time Traveller Artist
Lockdown Lancaster
A reminder of how different Lancaster looked and became during the period of Lockdown
From 26th March 2020 through both May and June the UK was in a state of ‘National Hibernation’ and we were all confined to within our houses and gardens.
Lancaster’s city centre, roads, streets, shops, buildings and workplaces became entirely different, empty and quiet places, devoid of cars, vans, lorries and buses, and presented a picture never seen before – and hopefully never again.
Andrew Reilly of Lancaster Past & Present went out with his camera on those empty streets and created two videos – Ghost Town and Lockdown Lancaster.
Sit back, watch them and then go out in and around the city and enjoy being able to walk around and enjoy our beautiful and historic city again.
Simple tips to save you money from our expert on energy saving
This year we need to look to make savings on our energy bills more than any other time in living memory. Peter Wiltshire is a member of Lancaster Civic Vision Executive Committee and also a qualified Commercial Energy Assessor with over twenty five years experience in most areas of construction.
He will be writing a series of articles to identify simple and easy actions that you can take around your home and save money on your energy bills – sometimes, as in today’s article, by simply turning a dial slightly.
His first – Save Eight per Cent on your Gas Bill is below
Save Eight Per Cent on your Gas Bill – Turn Down the ‘Flow’ Temperature on a Combi Boiler
A recent report by the Heating and Hot Water Council (HHIC)* found that households can save around six to eight per cent in gas just by turning down the heating flow temperature on their condensing combi boiler.
This is not just turning down the thermostat
Most combi boilers are not optimised to run as efficiently as they should, which increases household gas bills and emits more carbon. Reducing the operating temperature for heating will help your boiler run more efficiently without reducing your comfort.
We help you check if you have the right sort of boiler and show you how to make this simple change.
NB turning down your heating flow temperature is separate to setting your hot water temperature, this is covered in section 11.
Contents:
What does ‘turning down the flow temperature’ mean?
What type of boiler do I need?
How do I reduce the flow temperature?
What is the correct condensing boiler temperature setting?
Can I use trial and error?
Will I notice any changes in my heating system?
What if I have a health condition?
Where can I get more help with this?
Why have I not been advised about this before?
Is there anything else I can do to improve efficiency?
What temperature should my combi boiler be set at for hot water?
1) What does ‘turning down the flow temperature’ mean?
The ‘flow temperature’ is the temperature your boiler heats up the water to before sending it off to your radiators. Most gas boilers are set up to operate at what is called 80/60 flow and return temperatures. This means the boiler heats up the water (called ‘the flow’) to 80°C. The water returns to the boiler after travelling around all your radiators (called ‘the return’) at 60°C, having given off 20°C to the room.
However 80/60 flow and return temperatures are too high for a condensing gas boiler to achieve the A-rated efficiencies shown ‘on-the-box’. It is a little known fact that modern boilers have a variable efficiency between A-E, in other words they are not A-rated out of the box. Studies have found most to be C-E-Rated in the home, equivalent to just 75-85% efficiency.
Your installer should have reduced the flow temperature to give the boiler a chance to run in what is known as ‘condensing mode’ as much as possible. This is when it can recover the heat that was previously lost through the flue on old style boilers.
At 70/50°C the boiler will start to operate in condensing mode. Only when the flow temperature is 60°C or lower will the boiler recover enough heat to reach its higher efficiency potential.
2) What type of boiler do I need?
You will need to have a condensing combi boiler, i.e. a boiler that produces your heating and hot water. You will have a combi boiler if you do not have a hot water cylinder. It will definitely be a condensing boiler if it was fitted in the last 16 years. A condensing boiler will also have a white plastic pipe underneath the boiler (although it can be grey or black).
3) How do I reduce the flow temperature?
You need to go to the controls on front of your boiler. To be clear this is not your room thermostat, this sets the flow temperature for the boiler. The way in which you adjust the flow temperature and the display information available varies a great deal. Three common are examples are given below:
One or two dials
Most combi boilers have two dials: one for heating (usually with a little radiator icon over it) and one for hot water (with a little tap icon). Some only have one dial but it is usually for the heating flow temperatures. We’ve had lots of feedback on dials that do not provide the actual temperature setting. Some like Worcester are numbered 1-6, some have dashed lines and others a curved line of increasing thickness. Some user manuals do provide additional information.
If you have to work it out manually, then as a guide most boilers have flow temperatures that operate between 30°C-80°C. Which means 60°C will be about half way or the No. 3. We suggest setting to No.3 to begin with or at the half way mark (12 o’clock position). If there is a ‘e’ on the dial (not always present) it stands for ‘economy’ and will be around 70°C, so actually not that economical. Our advice is to ignore it.
Dials with digital displays
Some boilers have a dial but the flow temperature figure will appear in the digital display. Turn the dial with the radiator icon down until you reach 55-60°C. NB the boiler may not operate at the temperature set, rather it will target that temperature but reduce further when not needed. Our advice is not to get too distracted by what it does after you have turned the dial.
Digital displays with up and down buttons
Some newer boiler models have digital displays with up and down buttons or plus (+) and minus (-) buttons. You simply adjust the flow temperature via the ‘down’ or ‘minus’ button and the flow temperature figure will show in the digital display. Sometimes you have to press and hold a menu button to bring up the flow temperature, reduce it to 60°C, then press the menu button again to set (like setting the time on a cooker).
4) What is the correct condensing boiler temperature setting?
The correct temperature setting for heating on a combi boiler is ‘as low as possible’, but as a guide most older homes can run their heating systems at 60-65°C and newer homes at 50-55°C. They start to reach their very highest efficiency potential at 45°C flow temperature or lower, but this can be too low for older properties.
Ultimately how low you can turn your flow temperature down will depend on the size of your radiators, how well insulated your home is and your thermostat temperature.
Lower flow temperatures need more surface area of radiator to meet your desired room temperature; hence why we need much larger radiators for an air source heat pump. The good news is that most radiators are bigger than they need to be as the industry has sized based on guesswork or used basic online calculators that almost always overcompensate. We recommend trying it at 60°C. If you have a home built after 2010, try 50°C.
For homes with modern double glazing, cavity walls and good levels of loft insulation you should be able to drop your flow temperature down with no impact on comfort. Even older homes, particularly terraced houses, will be able to do this if they have been modernised and draft proofed.
5) Can I use trial and error?
Yes you can. Without an accurate heat loss calculation and radiator sizing exercise, it will be a matter of turning down the flow temperature and testing it to see if your house stays warm. You can turn it down little by little, or turn it down a lot and notch it back up if it doesn’t seem warm enough.
It may be that you can turn it down to below 60°C for most of the year but still need to notch it up in really cold weather.
6) Will I notice any changes in my heating system?
Yes. Your radiators will not feel so hot. This is a sign that the system is running a little cooler, which is what you are trying to achieve. Providing your home does not feel cold and you do not feel cold, the boiler and system are working correctly and more efficiently.
If you have your heating programmed to come on for a very limited amount of time, you may notice that it will take longer for your home to heat up. Many households are accustomed to short heat up times because they run so hot. Lower flow temperatures will mean slightly longer heat up times.
For those that have the heating on much of the day, you will move to lower temperatures for longer periods which will have a positive impact on fuel bills.
7) What if I have a health condition?
We would caveat the above advice for those with health conditions. Staying warm is very important and we would not wish you to risk your well being by adjusting your heating system on a trial and error basis.
8) Where can I get more help with this?
For more information on your boiler you can look in the instruction manual. You can usually find your manual on-line if you search for the make and model of your boiler. To be totally sure you have the right manual, find the boiler’s ‘GC’ number. Every boiler has one and its usually on the boiler’s data-plate. It will start with GC followed by a 7 digit number.
Alternatively you can ring the manufacturer’s technical helpline for customers. They will need the model or preferably the GC or serial number to help you with your particular boiler.
You can also ask your installer when you next have the boiler serviced. NB not all installers are familiar with condensing boiler technology, but should be able to assist with this function.
9) Why have I not been advised about this before?
A vast skills and knowledge gap (that dates back to 2005 when condensing gas boilers become mandatory) means 99% of installers do not understand how condensing gas boilers work and therefore cannot set them up to run as they were designed to. Installers have been let down and so have UK households. We have simply not benefited as much as we should have from this leap forward in boiler efficiency.
Part of our work is to educate households on their heating systems and help them get higher efficiencies from their existing boilers. The over-replacement of boilers is a problem in the UK. We want to see more existing boilers running optimally with small changes that reduce energy bills and our carbon footprint.
10) Is there anything else I can do to improve efficiency?
Yes lots. Lowering the flow temperature is just step 1. Most boilers are running 10-25% under their A-rated efficiency due to incorrect set up. A number of changes can be made to any boiler and heating system to tap latent efficiency. We help households invest in low cost efficiency measures to their existing boiler and heating system to harness untapped efficiency. To be clear we rarely advocate replacing a working, condensing boiler.
11) What temperature should my combi boiler be set at for hot water?
You can adjust your hot water temperature somewhat, but you must be mindful of legionella risks. Legionella is a bacteria that can occur in domestic hot water systems. It is more common in stored hot water, i.e. hot water cylinders, although still very rare .
There is a lower risk of legionella occurring in domestic dwellings that have a combi boiler (i.e. no hot water cylinder) and where there is daily usage of hot water. The HSE state that hot water outlets (taps and showers) should achieve 50-60°C. Depending on your levels of pipe insulation and length of the pipe runs, you may be able to set the hot water temperature on the boiler to 55°C, and possibly lower if you live in a modern flat or smaller modern home.
What is the solution? The boiler needs to be set up with separate heating and hot water temperatures, a low efficient temperature for heating and a high safe temperature for hot water. Adapting your boiler so it can supply a lower flow temperature for heating (that you can adjust) requires boiler-specific advice and some minor works to your system.
Peter’s next article in the series ‘Beat the Bills this Winter’ will be ‘Ventilation versus Draughts’ and is due to be published shortly
In its time Glasson has handled various cargoes for local industries which have waxed and waned. There was iron ore for the steel works in Carnforth; coal and cork for Williamson’s linoleum factory in Lancaster and the town’s gasworks; lime, fertilisers and feedstuffs for the farmers; timber and building materials. The port remains small – only for vessels up to 4000 tonnes
A printable version of this guide can be downloaded at the bottom of this page.
Glasson
Lancaster Civic Vision Guide 8
Getting there
Four miles (6km) south-west of Lancaster lies Glasson, a small village well worth a visit. It has been Lancaster’s port for over 230 years. By car, take the Lancaster–Blackpool road (the A588) and turn off to Glasson (the B5290). Park by the marina on your left. By bus, get the Lancaster to Knott End service (No. 89). On foot or by bicycle follow National Cycle Route No. 6, which uses the former railway line from Lancaster beside the River Lune.
How and why it started
A glance at a map or the satellite photograph above shows the navigation problem. From Morecambe Bay to Lancaster’s warehouses on St George’s Quay the River Lune repeatedly twists and turns. Taking a laden sailing ship from Ireland, the Baltic or the West Indies up the Lune was difficult, given often stormy winds from any direction, the high tidal range, shifting shoals and strong river currents when the Lune was in flood. The problem worsened as ships got bigger. The merchants wanted an outport nearer the sea and in 1787 Glasson opened. Because it is a dock it copes with the large tidal range but at the price of quayside access only twice a day around high water.
Walk along the East Quay, past the former Victoria Hotel (1830s), nineteenth-century cottages and Harbour House. Beyond the entrance to the dock you can see the sheds, the watch-house and red-and-white lighthouse by the dock gates. You get wonderful views of the estuary from here. The West Quay opposite was constructed in 1958 and also has limited public access. This was where the Nicholsons built ships (1834–1907) and Jesse Hartley built the dry dock for ship repairing (1840– 1969, now filled in).
The port
In its time Glasson has handled various cargoes for local industries which have waxed and waned. There was iron ore for the steel works in Carnforth; coal and cork for Williamson’s linoleum factory in Lancaster and the town’s gasworks; lime, fertilisers and feedstuffs for the farmers; timber and building materials. The port remains small – only for vessels up to 4000 tonnes – and it is managed by the Lancaster Port Commission established in the town in 1750 at St George’s Quay (see Guide 59). Many bulk trades moved to Preston after 1872, Fleetwood and, from 1904, Heysham Harbour. Only small coastal vessels can get into the dock or use the new quay out in the estuary. Glasson Grain – animal feeds – is currently the main employer. Around 150,000 tonnes of cargo a year are handled including fertiliser and building materials. There is a regular cargo service to the Isle of Man.
Canal and rail
Inland from the dock is the marina which occupies much of the canal basin. The far side of the marina is good for bird watching, as is the Lune estuary. The Lancaster Canal from Preston to Kendal reached Lancaster in 1797 (ten years after the dock opened) but the branch down six locks to Glasson did not arrive till 1825, traffic starting the following year.
Worse still for Glasson’s connectivity, the railway, which reached Lancaster from the south in 1840, did not get to Glasson till 1883. It was a single-track line, often four trains a day, which closed to passengers in 1930 and for goods to Glasson in 1964.
The marina hosts both canal-boats and large ocean-going yachts – chandlery is a major activity on the site of the old warehouse (1825–1939). The Glasson Sailing Club reinforces the leisure side of Glasson that complements the industrial traffic.
Other places to visit
If you walk along the canal, you soon come to Christ Church. This delightful church was designed by Edmund Sharpe, a noted Lancaster architect, and the stained glass (by Shrigley & Hunt) is well worth studying for its many local references. There are separate leaflets on Stained Glass in Lancaster (No. 6)and Edmund Sharpe (No. 32).
If you return to the dock, cross the swing bridge between the marina and dock and walk up the hill. You pass a row of neat cottages on your right, Ten Row (1835) and then Norfolk House (c. 1850), the home of a Lancaster merchant who appreciated the superb all-round view. Across the Lune lies Sunderland Point (See Guide 9 in this series) and the Irish Sea.
To the north-west are the nuclear power stations at Heysham. To the north are the hills of the southern Lake District and to the north-east lies Lancaster, the green dome of the Ashton Memorial (Guide No. 55) being clear.
To the east are the white roofs of Lancaster University (Guide No. 38) and beyond these the Forest of Bowland, part of the Pennines (Guide No. 41). There is a viewing platform which points out these and other sites.
If you return to Glasson by the road which curves down along the estuary on your left, you will pass the factory on the site of Nicholson’s shipyard which until recently manufactured car exhausts and is now run by Glasson Grain.
At the foot of this road, a left turn takes you in 100 metres to the offices of the Port Commissioners and the Port of Lancaster Smokehouse and delicatessen. A right turn takes you along Ten Row and back to the Dock itself. Glasson’s pub (the Dalton Arms) serves food and there is a café, snack bar, shop, primary school and public toilets. Enjoy your visit!
Lancaster Canal enters Marina Basin
Marina locks to Dock beyond
Glasson to Lune Estuary, Sunderland Point and Irish Sea
The feature for this weekend is Glasson. Taking a laden sailing ship from Ireland, the Baltic or the West Indies up the Lune was difficult, given often stormy winds from any direction, the high tidal range, shifting shoals and strong river currents when the Lune was in flood.
The problem worsened as ships got bigger. The merchants wanted an outport nearer the sea and in 1787 Glasson opened, however it took till 1883 to open the branch line to Lancaster.
Tomorrow we look at the history of Glasson
A printable version of this guide can be downloaded at the bottom of this page.
The Train to Glasson
Lancaster Civic Vision Guide 108
In Guide 8 in this series we traced the growth of Glasson. The quay on the river opened in 1781/2, the dock in 1787 and the link to the Lancaster Canal in 1826. Despite the railway reaching Lancaster from Preston in 1840 it took till 1883 to open the branch to Glasson.
The line left Lancaster (Castle) Station just north of the platforms and, turning west, went down a 1 in 50 gradient. It passed St George’s Works, the town’s gas works and Williamson’s Lune Mills before turning south. It then followed the River Lune till, turning west again at Conder Green it ran into Glasson station. The tracks continued beyond the station to serve the dock.
The route along the Lune as shown on the OS one-inch map of 1947
The route leaves Lancaster (Castle) Station (bottom right) and travels north-west then south-west. Note the industrial sites and the District Engineer’s yard and workshops off the Glasson branch (OS six-inch map of 1938).
The tracks at Glasson in 1910 (OS six-inch map). The tracks split west of the station to serve the dock and riverside quay.
It was a single-track line with level crossings at Aldcliffe and Stodday, a request Halt for Ashton Hall and a request Station at Conder Green. The Lancaster to Glasson journey – nearly five miles – took 16 minutes without a stop at Conder Green, 19 with one. In the 1920s there were four trains in each direction for passengers on weekdays. Competition from buses and cars led to the closure of the passenger service in 1930. The line remained open for goods traffic which was always important in this line’s finances.
Glasson Station (Source: commercial postcard and Richardson 2022)
Unloading cargo on to railway wagons around 1900.
The cargo tracks dock-side at Glasson after 1903.
After the passenger service closed it was the freight traffic that kept the line open. From the docks at various times came iron ore, coal, timber, linseed oil and nitrochalk. At the Lancaster end of the line there were considerable goods flows inward and outward for St George’s Works, Lune Mills and the town’s gas works. This included coal, coke, materials for making linoleum and Williamson’s finished products. There were sidings off the Glasson line into the gas works, quayside and Lune Mills connecting with the latter’s extensive internal system.
By the 1960s freight traffic was also declining and the Glasson branch was closed and lifted from Glasson to Freeman’s Wood in 1964 and fully closed in 1971. Today the route is a footpath.
The author has relied on David Richardson’s book Lancaster’s Line to the Sea: a History of the Glasson Branch of the LNWR. (Cumbrian Railways Association, 2022) in the preparation of this guide. This book provides an extensive, well-researched and well-illustrated account of the line.