Planning Scrutiny Group have grave concerns over the proposed demolition of Lile Tool Shop

Lancaster Civic Society are a statutory consultee for all planning applications received by Lancaster City Council and have a dedicated Planning Scrutiny Group (PSG) who comment accordingly on all applications they receive.

A planning application has been received by the City Council from Mister Group, Lancaster regarding the premises at 41A – 45 North Road, Lancaster – formerly the Lile Tool shop.

Lile Tool Shop – Photo courtesy Andrew Reilly, Lancaster Past & Present

This application – reference 21/00007/FUL is to demolish the premises and erect in its place a student accommodation development to house sixteen students.

PSG have grave concerns regarding this particular application as the buildings proposed for demolition is identified by Lancaster City Council in their Heritage Action Zone document for the Mill Race Area as “positive buildings”. A copy of the full document Mill Race Conservation Management Plan Stage 1 (Draft) can be read/downloaded here:

Indeed, it has been noted by the PSG that the buildings on either side of this proposed development have already been ‘sensitively’ rebuilt or converted.

Shop front as it now appears in the Planning Application

The Civic Society have already expressed their concern to the City Council in August 2021 stating that the frontage of Lile Tool Shop must be maintained irrespective of any future use of this building.

They were particularly anxious that the Council must take steps to ensure that the owners of the property do more to protect it from further damage whilst its future is debated as we may well end up with a similar situation to the Crown Hotel, which was forced to be demolished from a safety aspect.

Listed below are some of the key issues that PSG consider should be taken into account regarding this building:

  • A building with strong links with Lancaster’s industrial heritage since the tool shop was much used by Gillows’ craftsmen whose workshops were nearby.
  • An example of a genuine specialist retail outlet 
  • Has been allowed to fall into near dereliction through neglect over a number of years
  • It now stands out as an eye-sore on a prominent site
  • Is in a flood risk area
  • Buildings on either side have been sensitively re-built or converted 
  • The proposed new use is for student accommodation which the Civic Society has already warned is in over-supply,

Whilst the building is not a listed property it is within a conservation area and it could be considered for local listing as a Non-designated Heritage Asset.

Shop identified (ringed) on Mackreth’s 1778 map – from the planning application

PSG have yet to submit their responses but would welcome comments from members of the public to this application. If you wish to respond please complete the form at the end of this article.

Additionally, you add your own comments to the application by following that link to the City Council Applications web page – https://www.lancaster.gov.uk/planning/view-applications-and-decisions –  and using reference 21/00007/FUL.