Wednesday Walk – The Development of Haverbreaks

Not really a walk as Haverbreaks is a private estate but an interesting leaflet looking at the development of this exclusive area that was originally to be called The Albert Park.

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet No. 72

The district of Lancaster known as Haverbreaks is distinctive among the housing areas of the city.  Its large houses set amid spacious gardens are unparalleled in Lancaster. Until the later nineteenth century the site was just fields – rectangular like most fields around the town after the Enclosure process. Topographically it is a low, oval hill with Haverbreaks house and farm at its centre, accessed by the bridge from Aldcliffe Road (originally Aldcliffe Lane) 0ver Lancaster Canal.  The Ordnance Survey map of 1845 shows the details.

The Haverbreaks area c.1845 (Source: Ordnance Survey, 6-inch map, first edition)

In the early 1870s a consortium including William Ford of Ellel Hall and Harrison and Hall (Lancaster surveyors) bought the Haverbreaks site from the Royal Albert Asylum (whose recently completed hospital adjoined Haverbreaks) intending to create a model suburb near the town but away from its pollution, bustle and bye-laws.  The title of the plan (below) shows that “The Albert Park” was the initial preferred name for this development.

Title and cartouche of the 1875 Plan for Haverbreaks

The plan itself shows that the aim was clearly up-market – very large building plots allowing for expensive villas and expansive gardens. Restrictive covenants were placed on buyers and owners to retain this style. The architects used for the houses were scrutinised. The expansion of Lancaster’s boundaries into parts of Scotforth parish brought the site within the remit of the Corporation in 1880 and we can then trace its development more fully. A road network was built, first around the edges of the estate, now called Haverbreaks Road and Brettargh Drive – Brettargh after the Ford family’s property, Brettargh Holt near Kendal.  Stanmore Drive was widened and realigned from ‘The Lane’ in 1933.

Progress with building was slow. The market for such expensive houses was limited in Lancaster and Haverbreaks was a big site.  The earliest houses were around the western and northern edges of the estate – among them were Haverbreaks (now redeveloped), Thornbreaks, Elmsfield (with its boat house on the canal), Oatlands (also redeveloped) and Yewgarth. There was also the lodge house by the Canal bridge. Houses were named not numbered. Several were in the fashionable Arts and Crafts style.  Some had gardens designed by the Mawson firm of landscape architects (see Leaflet No. 46).

William Ford died in 1898 and a new plan was then drawn up for the estate (below), this one further dividing some of the plots to allow for smaller, somewhat more affordable properties.

The plan for the auction of Haverbreaks building plots in 1898

The aim of encouraging more building succeeded because by 1913 there were 23 houses on Haverbreaks (see below).

Haverbreaks in 1913 (Source: Ordnance Survey, 1:2500, revised 1910, published 1913)

Ten more houses were built between the world wars. After 1945 more, even smaller houses were built on new roads on the northern and north-eastern sides of the estate.  Building has continued slowly in recent years.

Haverbreaks remains a private estate, guided by its Residents Association and favoured now, as in the late nineteenth century, by Lancaster’s more successful business people and senior members of the professions. It has taken around 150 years to build on nearly all the plots (see the satellite image below).

Haverbreaks (and Nazareth House) in 2021 (Source: Google Earth)

More information about the early development of Haverbreaks, on which this leaflet and its images are based, can be found in:-

Stansfield C (2016) The development of Haverbreaks, Lancaster, 1875–1913. Contrebis 34, 13–23.

This is available online at https://lahs.archaeologyuk.org, which is the website of Lancaster Archaeological and Historical Society.

Text – Gordon  Clark. Published by Lancaster Civic Society (©2021). www.lancastercivicsociety.uk.

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over sixty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

Our next meeting is on 15th September – Visit to Morecambe Winter Gardens – Lecture about the Winter Gardens by Professor Vanessa Toulmin (Chair of the Winter Gardens Preservation Trust) followed by a guided tour of the building and ending with afternoon tea accompanied by Peter Jetson giving an organ recital. Members only for this event.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page

Weekend Walk – The Priory Church of St Mary, Lancaster

Until 1755 the Priory Church of St Mary was Lancaster’s only church.

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet 56

The Tower

It stands on a most prominent position atop Castle Hill and next to the Castle. The site was on the northern flank of the Roman forts built here, of which very little remains above ground. The Church is Grade 1 listed.

There is some evidence for a Saxon church on this site dated to the 8th or 9th centuries and surviving in some stone fragments. There are small sections of the Norman Benedictine Priory on this site, preserved in parts of the walls. The Benedictine Priory became the Priory Church of St Mary in the Parish of Lancaster in 1430.

The majority of the nave, chancel and chancel aisles are from the 14th and 15th centuries in a Perpendicular style.  The most important feature of the interior is the elaborately carved choir stalls and their misericords (carved fold-down seats), which date to around 1340 and are considered to be among the best in the country.

The Choir Stalls

There was a medieval tower on the west side, which became unsafe and was replaced by the present tower (designed by Henry Sephton) in the 1750s. This was followed by extensive and repeated internal refurbishments of the interior, with galleries removed and organs replaced. The gallery survives at the west end where the organ is, and it displays a carved Royal coat of arms.

The pulpit has woodwork dated 1619. The roof is 19th century. The SW porch and vestries were added in the 20th century. The chapel in the NW corner for the King’s Own Lancaster Regiment was opened in 1903/4. The stained glass is mostly mid-Victorian, some, including the East window by William Wailes. The best stained glass is at the east end of the South aisle – a figure of Christ by R F Ashmead of Lancaster’s Abbott & Co. (1966).  The work of the town’s other major stained- glass firm, Shrigley and Hunt, is also represented in the church.  There are a large number of brasses (some by A W N Pugin) and sculptures, including a Madonna by Shawn Williamson.

The burial ground to the west has been re-arranged, the gravestones laid flat and seating provided.   

St Thomas, in Lancaster Priory by R.F. Ashmead of Abbott & Co (1966)

The Civic Society together with the RSPB are erecting a plaque to Emily Williamson – ‘the Lancaster woman who saved a million birds’ and founder of the RSPB and who was born in Lancaster and baptised in the Priory Church later this year.

There will also be a celebratory event together with an exhibition in the Priory.

For further information and to donate towards this visit the RSPB Crowdfunding page here

Reading

C Hartwell and N Pevsner The Building s of England. Lancashire: North. New Haven and London: Yale

   University Press.

The Priory’s guide book.

Text and photographs – Gordon Clark.     

Published by Lancaster Civic Society (2020).

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over sixty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

Our next meeting is on 15th September – Visit to Morecambe Winter Gardens – Lecture about the Winter Gardens by Professor Vanessa Toulmin (Chair of the Winter Gardens Preservation Trust) followed by a guided tour of the building and ending with afternoon tea accompanied by Peter Jetson giving an organ recital. Members only for this event.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page

City Council Discussion and Vote to Exclude Public and Press

Lancaster City Council have tabled a motion that the discussion and vote on the proposed 9,000+ homes in South Lancaster should be held ‘in camera’.

Lancaster City Council will on Wednesday 25th August hold an Extraordinary meeting at the Town Hall in Morecambe to discuss and vote on the Collaboration Agreement – South Lancaster Growth Catalyst.

If passed this will pave the way for around 9,185 homes to be built in the South Lancaster area.

The Civic Society has leaned that the City Council have added an item to the agenda prior to discussion of this matter requesting that Councillors vote to exclude both public and press to this discussion and vote under the terms:

“That, in accordance with Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act, 1972, the press and public be excluded from the meeting for the following item of business, on the grounds that it could involve the possible disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 3 of Schedule 12A of that Act.” 

Lancaster Civic Society have issued the following statement to all Lancaster City Councillors and would urge citizens who agree to contact their Councillor and request them to vote against this motion.

“We are dismayed to learn that it is intended to ask Council to agree to exclude the press and public from the consideration of the item on Collaboration Agreement – South Lancaster Growth Catalyst.”

“It is accepted that the Collaboration Agreement contains some specific matters of a confidential nature that cannot be shared or discussed in public. However we are dubious that this can apply to the entire Agreement.”

“There is nothing to stop the Authority holding a confidential briefing session for all members which would allow for these specific confidential matters to be presented and discussed with members in private. This could take place immediately before the commencement of the Council meeting.”

“We think it is quite wrong that because some aspects of the Collaboration Agreement are confidential that the whole matter should be dealt with as an exempt item.”

“This is a matter of great interest and consequence and a Council that has previously stressed the importance of meaningful engagement should not be preventing the public witness the debate on this matter.“

“We would therefore urge you to vote against the proposal to exclude the press and public.”

Lancaster Civic Society -20th August 2021

Lancaster groups air concerns over £260m south Lancaster development ahead of city council decision

With Lancaster City Council expected to discuss major development plans for south Lancaster next week, two local groups have had their say on why they believe making a decision so soon could be a risky move

by Gayle Rouncivell – Lancaster Guardian, 19th August 2021

An artist’s impression of how part of the Bailrigg Garden Village scheme might look.

Lancaster City Council is expected to make a decision at a special meeting on August 25 on whether to accept £140m of Housing Investment Funding (HIF), which would form part of a larger plan for the development of more than 9,000 new homes in south Lancaster and a major reconfiguring of junction 33 of the M6 and surrounding roads.

Many residents have already made their feelings clear about the development, while council leader Caroline Jackson said the proposal has the potential to be ‘the biggest decision in 20 to 30 years’ that Lancaster City Council will have to make.

Here, both CLOUD (Citizens of Lancaster Opposed to Unnecessary Development) and Lancaster Civic Society tell us their views on the scheme, and why they believe the decision-making process needs to be further delayed.

The proposed Bailrigg Garden Village development site.

CLOUD

Local residents welcomed the opportunity provided by council leader Caroline Jackson for public discussion about the South Lancaster Growth Catalyst (SLGC), which includes the Bailrigg Garden Village development. Two briefing sessions were held on August 4 and 11.

They were the first time that residents were able to put key questions to council officers about the evidence for – and impact of – the 9,185 new houses proposed for south Lancaster.

A special meeting of Lancaster City Council has been called for August 25 to decide whether to accept a Housing Infrastructure Fund grant which would cover part but not all the of the associated infrastructure costs.

An artist’s impression of how part of the Bailrigg Garden Village scheme might look.

An artist’s impression of how part of the Bailrigg Garden Village scheme might look.

However, the sessions raised more concerns and questions than answers. In particular :

● Residents asked repeatedly for evidence to support uplifting the housing target from 3,500 (agreed in the 2019 Local Plan) to the current figure of 9,185. This equates to a new town of 30,000 people – rather more than the population of Kendal! Council officers’ attempts to justify the 9,185 figure as only a ‘business case figure’ met with scepticism.

● The briefing sessions were told that housing developers would be expected to contribute to infrastructure costs through payment of a ‘roof tax’. The high level of such funding needed for south Lancaster, combined with evidence from other developments that developers find ways of reducing or even avoiding paying the tax altogether, led to real doubts that this amount of roof tax could be secured.

● There are very serious financial risks for the city council which it appears are only just beginning to be understood and made public. It would seem that any shortfalls on the massive £261m budget would have to be picked up by council tax payers.

Part of the development site for Bailrigg Garden Village. Photo: Google

● The impact on already stretched local health provision was reported in the Lancaster Guardian on July 22 2021. Similar concerns surround the provision of schools for the additional residents of south Lancaster.

● It would seem that we would be facing 25 years of construction traffic as the south Lancaster development is expected to extend into the 2040s. It’s not hard to see why residents are so worried.

● And all this in the same week that the UN has published its Climate Change Report which will surely make Lancaster residents sit up and think about whether they want developers to concrete over a extensive greenfield site, increasing both carbon emissions and the risk of flooding in an area which has all too recently suffered as a result of extreme weather events.

● One final question – why the rush? The city council has been asked to meet on August 25 to take a final decision on whether to go ahead and approve the the HIF money. Given that there are still so many unanswered questions and councillors are being asked to vote on the biggest strategic issue in the city for over 20 years, it seems almost farcical that a date in the middle of the holidays, when some councillors are likely to be away, has been chosen. The reason being given for the August date is a deadline of August 30 for the council to sign the legally binding Partnership Agreement.

In view of the scale and gravity of this matter, the CLOUD group is calling for the decision to be deferred until there has been an honest and open debate with the wider community – and for all concerned to be in possession of the full facts and evidence.

After all at full council on March 24 2021, a petition was tabled signed by 718 residents regarding the rushed nature of the Master Planning process. Janice Hanson, deputy leader of the council, said that she recognised the frustration experienced by residents and accepted that substantive issues had been raised.

She therefore made a recommendation. Council was asked ‘to mandate that consultation on the subsequent South Lancaster Area Action Plan should include structured questions and provide feedback to those registering comments/objections’.

This was seconded by Coun Gina Dowding, who gave a strong critique of existing consultation problems. This was passed unopposed by Lancaster City Council. Surely time should now be provided for proper residents’ consultation over the HIF bid, in the spirit of that vote?

LANCASTER CIVIC SOCIETY

Lancaster Civic Society are extremely disappointed about the lack of public consultation over the far-reaching implications of accepting Housing Infrastructure Fund monies.

We fully appreciate that the resolution of many long-standing transportation issues depends on the receipt of this funding.

However, we are of the view that there has been insufficient opportunity for a proper and robust engagement with the local community on this most important matter.

We cannot understand why it took until August for the city council to engage with the local community on this issue, when it was considered by Cabinet on June 8. We find this delay baffling.

The subject of the report was not listed on the published agenda for the Cabinet on June 8 and it was taken as an urgent item.

The city council must have been in discussion with the county council following their decisions on HIF in early 2021; it is therefore puzzling that it had to be dealt with as an urgent item.

Whilst the report was public, it contained an exempt appendix and the cabinet was advised that the matter would be considered during the confidential part of the meeting.

It is remarkable that the public report makes no reference to the obligation on the city council to support the provision of over 9,000 new dwellings in south Lancaster, as this is probably the most controversial aspect of the entire issue.

The public report contains an options appraisal which we consider to be extremely superficial for an issue of this magnitude. We hope that the exempt appendix contained a more robust analysis for cabinet members to consider

The justification used for dealing with the appendix as an exempt item was Schedule 12A, paragraph 3, of the Local Government Act 1972.

This relates to the financial or business affairs of any particular person (including the authority holding that information). This could not apply to the specific issue of supporting the provision of over 9,000 new homes in south Lancaster, and the consequential planning implications of any such decision. This information is of considerable public interest and could have been included in the public report.

The report of June 8 provided an important opportunity for the city council to properly articulate, in a public document, the arguments for and against accepting the HIF offer, particularly with regard to the obligation to facilitate over 9,000 new homes.

Had this happened there would have been ample time to consult on this and report back before making a final decision prior to the deadline of August 30. We do not understand why the council did not do this.

We consider the way the council has handled this issue to be in contradiction of its previous commitments to meaningful community engagement.

On August 6 2019 the city council cabinet approved a report on the “establishment of Advisory Groups for Cabinet members to engage with communities and stakeholders”.

The report stated that “The cabinet has expressed its intention to establish a network of groups to facilitate meaningful engagement and discussion with communities and stakeholders…”

This was a very positive commitment on the part of the city council to meaningful engagement with the local community, and the council took this so seriously that it amended the constitution to reflect this new approach.

However, the manner in which this issue has been dealt with falls very short of the commitment to “meaningful engagement and discussion” given in August 2019.

The city council propose to take a decision on this issue on August 25. This decision is one of the most far reaching that the city council has ever taken. To date the only opportunity for public engagement with the city council on this critical issue has been two Teams sessions, the first lasting 70 minutes, the second an hour.

At both sessions there were significant numbers of questions from the public that could not be addressed in the time available.

At both Teams sessions it was stated that the Local Plan, which had been subject to considerable public consultation, had identified the possibility of significant additional new housing, and had stated that a minimum of 3,500 new homes would be provided in south Lancaster.

It was stressed that that this had always been regarded as a minimum and not a target. The inference that we took from these comments was that the Local Plan consultation process had provided ample opportunity for public comment on the possibility of significant numbers of new houses in South Lancaster, and that no one should now be overly surprised by the suggestion of an uplift in the proposed number to over 9,000.

It is correct that the Local Plan Policy SC1 does state “a minimum of 3,500” but it also contains the following paragraph: “Policy SP6 of this DPD sets out the overall housing target and identifies a wide range of development sites which will be required to meet that Local Housing Need. The broad location for growth has identified opportunities to deliver in the region of 3,500 new homes, 1,205 of which the council believes can be realistically delivered during the course of this plan period up to 2034, due to the strategic infrastructure required to facilitate growth.”

You will note that this paragraph uses the phrase “in the region of 3,500″. We would contend that the combined effect of these two phases within the Local Plan would have led any reader [and perhaps the Local Plan Inspector] to reasonably conclude that whist there might be more than 3500 new homes delivered in south Lancaster it would still be in the region of 3500 i.e., a bit more, but certainly not 9,000+.

At both Teams sessions it was also asserted that the issues of the Local Plan and HIF were being wrongly “converged and conflated” However, in our view the two issues have become conflated. If the HIF agreement is signed, then this will partially predetermine future local plans.

The city council will be obliged to facilitate the provision of over 9,000 new homes in South Lancaster, which in turn will require the allocation, through the local planning process, of sufficient land to accommodate this. The only consideration [on this matter] for the local plan process will be to determine where these should be built.

We appreciate that the council has been advised that it must sign the legally binding Partnership Agreement by August 30. However, we believe that the county council has until 2027 to spend the HIF grant.

We cannot understand why a short extension to the identified deadline of August 30 to sign the Partnership Agreement could not be negotiated to allow time for meaningful consultation.

We would therefore urge the city council to defer taking a decision on August 25 to allow time for a public consultation exercise commensurate with the magnitude of this matter to the future of our city.

Civic Society to address Extraordinary Meeting of the City Council on the Implications of Accepting HIF Monies.

The decision before the Council Meeting on 25th August is one of the most far reaching that has ever been taken.

Lancaster Civic Society will attend the Extraordinary Council meeting to be held on 25th August at the Town Hall in Morecambe to address the Councillors prior to their vote on accepting the £260m city expansion project.

We are urging the City Council to defer a decision in order to allow time for a public consultation exercise commensurate with the magnitude of this matter to the future of our city.

The full text of our address is set out below for your information and we would urge all citizens who agree with our position to contact both City and County Councillors immediately to record your objections.

A full list of City Councillors can be found on the Lancaster City Council web page here.

Don’t ‘put a millstone around our children’s neck’, urges former climate advisor appealing to Lancaster city councillors

The former climate change advisor to a Labour shadow chancellor has appealed to Lancaster councillors to reject a £260 million housing and road development in South Lancaster for the sake of future generations.

by Michael Blade – Lancashire Post, 17 August 2021

Former Labour MP Alan Simpson, who was climate and sustainable economics advisor to shadow chancellor John McDonnell, said a transformative change in mindset is needed towards future infrastructure development, and this is an opportunity for Lancaster councillors to show courage and vision.

He was speaking in a recorded interview, carried out by Lancaster Youth for the Environment (LYFE), to be presented at a public meeting on Thursday evening, about the planned development of the new Bailrigg Garden Community and Junction 33.

Lancaster City Council will be deciding whether to support the development at the Council meeting next Wednesday.

An artist’s impression of how some of Bailrigg Garden Village might look. Image from JTP Architects

Referring to the recent report by the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), Mr Simpson said: “The main point that the IPCC have made, is that we have little choice. If we want to avoid the really serious climate breakdown, we have to engage in transformative thinking on a scale that is unprecedented. In practical terms, it requires the UK to cut our carbon emissions by 10% a year, throughout the entirety of this decade.

“It means we can’t go on running with notions of conventional growth and recovery. We can’t go on assuming that we’ll just build a whole raft of new housing, without there being carbon consequences for doing that. And we can’t build in any developments that themselves are premised around increasing the transport consequences, or they increase fuel consumption, just for the people who live there but work elsewhere.”

He urged councillors to consider ‘is this a proposal that has been reached after looking at all of the existing properties that you have in Lancaster that could be reclaimed or refurbished or repurposed, without incurring the carbon costs of new construction?’.

“If effectively, you’re building a new estate of 9000 houses, that is really about being within commuting distance of Preston and Manchester, then you’re just pouring carbon problems onto the lap of all of those who follow.”

An artist’s impression of how some of the housing might look in Bailrigg Garden Village. Image from JTP Architects.

He said that if councillors were tempted by the £140 million being offered by the government toward the road infrastructure for the development, they would be kidding themselves at the expense of their children and grandchildren.

He suggested Lancaster could learn from concepts like 15-minutes cities, being considered in Newcastle and elsewhere, which encourage people to live and work locally because what they need is within 15 minutes’ walk.

“I would ask local councillors just to step back from and ask themselves have they rigorously answered the question about that carbon millstone that they would otherwise hang around children’s necks?”

He asked councillors to show courage at the Council meeting next Wednesday, which will decide whether to support the proposal.

He asked councillors to show courage at the Council meeting next Wednesday, which will decide whether to support the proposal.

“You’re the people that we put in office now, to help us avoid the worst of what might follow. And some of those decisions will be based around just agreeing not to do the things that would make life worse.”

Lancaster Youth For Environment (LYFE) echoed Alan’s call to consider their futures saying: “This development has been planned without ample community consultation or any acknowledgment or assessment of the huge carbon impacts associated. This level of hasty, minimally appraised development, only two years after a climate emergency declaration is unacceptable. It leads us to question the motives of Lancashire County Council and the City Council – where is the community wealth building assessment? The circular economy assessment? And for what and who are they chasing development and growth at a clear cost to the community and our collective futures?”

LYFE urged councillors and citizens to attend the online public meeting this Thursday at 7pm to hear detail and discuss why this development conflicts with numerous community and climate priorities. The interview with Alan Simpson will be played alongside a live discussion with Friends of the Earth road transport campaigner Jenny Bates and Lancaster Cabinet member for climate change Kevin Frea.

LYFE is asking “for an extension to the hasty August 25 decision deadline so that proper consultation can take place and climate and community impacts can be assessed. Other options for housing exist, we cannot simply continue with business as usual, all we ask is that these options are considered and that the council follows through on its promise to value our future.”

Register and join the event here

Wednesday Walk – The Ashton Memorial

The Ashton Memorial is Lancaster’s most obvious landmark and perhaps its best known.

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet 55

It stands to the east of the city on a site 70 metres above even the top of Castle Hill. The 45-metre memorial is readily visible to travellers passing Lancaster on the train or M6. You can see its green dome and white stonework from many parts of the town itself.

The Ashton Memorial, Lancaster

The memorial sits at the heart of Williamson Park, which till the 1840s was the site one of the town’s quarries for building stone – the quarry faces can still be seen. The area was landscaped in the 1870s by James Williamson, the textile and linoleum magnate.

His son, also James Williamson (and later Lord Ashton) gave the land to the town in 1881 as a public park with funds to maintain it. He also embellished the park with a bandstand (no longer there), shelters and a stone bridge (replacing a wooden one) over the man-made lake. This was one of Lord Ashton’s many gifts to Lancaster, both large and small.

He commissioned the Ashton Memorial in 1904, just after his wife died, having probably had it in mind for some time. It was constructed in 1906–9. His chosen architect was the nationally renowned Sir John Blecher aided by J J Boass.  Their preferred style, then fashionable, is variously called High or Edwardian Baroque, which they had used on previous commissions.

The key point is that Lord Ashton spent a huge sum on the building – some say £63,000 and others say £80,000. The equivalent in 2019 money is between £7.6 and £9.6 million. The architects did not hesitate to spend it, creating a lavish and complex building.

There are three layers to the building from the ground floor to the lantern above the dome. The more you study the building, the more you appreciate the complexity of its design. The basic structure is a steel frame rising from deep foundations and in-filled with load-bearing brick and reinforced concrete. The whole structure below the copper-clad dome is faced in white Portland limestone. Leading up the building are long flights of steps in speckled Cornish granite.

The Lancaster crest

Inside the building the ground floor has a strikingly decorative floor, elaborate light fittings and allegorical paintings on the ceiling by George Murray. There is a family commemoration on a plaque.

Steps lead up to smaller rooms and to balconies with wonderful views in all directions. From the balconies you get a better view of the four sculptures on the outside representing Commerce, Science, Industry and Art that were created by Herbert Hampson. He also designed the Queen Victoria Monument in Dalton Square, another gift from Lord Ashton in 1909.

Lord Ashton’s initials on the Ashton Memorial, Lancaster

The Williamson family funded repairs to the building in 1930 and it suffered some damage in a fire in 1962.  In 1981 the whole building was closed to the public because it had become structurally unsound and it was threatened with demolition. Water had seeped in and rusted the steel reinforcing bars in the concrete, which caused the bars to expand and crack the concrete. However, a major fund-raising campaign allowed the city to pay for repairs in 1985–7.

Lord Ashton originally intended the Queen Victoria Monument to be the pinnacle of the Park. The Memorial displaced the royal monument to Dalton Square. People have speculated on why he chose this enormous design. He was not an easy man to understand.

The idea of it as a memorial to his late wife has been replaced by seeing it as a legacy from the wider family to Lancaster. Certainly it has been hard to find a use for it.

The Palm House or Orangery next to it is an obvious visitor attraction, now a butterfly house, and with a cafe and gift shop nearby. But finding a use for the Memorial itself has been harder. It was a local museum for a while. Now it is a wedding venue as well as a place to visit and admire. It verges on being a folly – a glorious structure without a clear use but desired by a man so rich he could afford to build it.

The Palm House and Lancashire Rose stone mosaic, Williamson Park, Lancaster

Reading

S. Ashworth 1989 The Lino King: The Life and Times of Lord Ashton. Lancaster: Lancaster City Museum

Text and photographs – Gordon Clark.     

Published by Lancaster Civic Society (© 2020).

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over sixty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

Our next meeting is on 15th September – Visit to Morecambe Winter Gardens – Lecture about the Winter Gardens by Professor Vanessa Toulmin (Chair of the Winter Gardens Preservation Trust) followed by a guided tour of the building and ending with afternoon tea accompanied by Peter Jetson giving an organ recital. Members only for this event.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page

Weekend Walk – Freehold, Lancaster

The Freehold area in Lancaster catches your eye – for its rectangular street pattern and for its modern legalistic name. How can these distinctive features be explained?

Lancaster Civic Society Leaflet No. 71

The rectangular street pattern of Freehold today, viewed from the west
(Source: Google Earth)

In the early nineteenth century the two-party Parliamentary system comprised the Whigs (who became the Liberals later in the century) and the Tories/Conservatives. The right to vote in a constituency was traditionally available only to its male property owners – the so-called ‘forty shilling freeholders’. The Representation of the People Act of 1832 extended voting rights in counties and boroughs to include some copyholders, leaseholders and tenants. This was a modest extension of the franchise that both parties believed could benefit them electorally, the Whigs in the towns and cities and the Tories in the countryside.

The Whigs in particular saw increasing the number of borough freeholders and other property owners as a route to greater electoral success locally and nationally.  Following pioneering groups in Birmingham, London and Manchester over a hundred Freehold Land Society estates were set up across the country using money raised to buy land and sell house plots to builders and new freeholders.

The National Freehold Land Society and the Second Freehold Building Society set up a Lancaster Branch in 1848 and offered £100 shares for sale, and they raised more than the £6,500 (£928,000 in 2020 values) needed to buy in 1852 the 38 acres of what came to be known as ‘Freehold Park’. The fields they bought are shown in the centre of the map below – between Bath House and Highfield and between Moor Place Farm and the municipal boundary. The field boundaries coincide with the development’s shape. 

The site of Freehold in 1844 (Source: Ordnance Survey)

A plan for the streets, a drainage system and house plots was drawn up in 1852, creating 364 house plots for sale at £30 a plot, payable at 1 shilling a week. By December 1853 only a few plots remained unsold. The long, thin gardens, the views over the town and beyond, and the broad, clean streets made this an attractive area for those who could afford to buy. Rydal, Dalton and Borrowdale Roads rose the 100 feet or so from Ulleswater /Ullswater Road to Derwent Road.

The first house went up on Derwent Road in 1853. However, the ability to build and sell new houses was limited in Lancaster (a small town without rapid population growth) and the economy in the 1850s and 1860s was not particularly buoyant. This was a very large development for a town the size of Lancaster, therefore house-building was steady over the next two decades rather than rapid.

As early as 1855 some newly-built houses were being sold on. However, by 1877 all the streets (except for some of the larger plots on Borrowdale and Derwent Roads) had been substantially built up.  Building continued more slowly into the 1890s and there have been some new houses in recent years. The houses, built over several decades by many different builders, vary in style and size. The smallest are terraced, one room wide and only two storeys: often on the western side of Freehold. Others are three storeys, and higher up on the eastern side the houses are larger, being semi-detached or detached.

Freehold in 1877, west at the top
(Source: Harrison and Hall map, via Lancaster University Library and Andrew White)

Did the political aim succeed? Perhaps, but only slowly as the new houses went up and were sold. As early as 1855 some of the houses were being rented rather than sold. In 1861 there were 102 households but only 30 freehold owners.

Freehold in 1891 (Source: Ordnance Survey)

The Representation of the People Acts of 1867 and 1885 gradually extended voting rights to men who were resident in an area but were not property owners. Also the extensive corruption through voter bribery in Lancaster elections up to 1865 undermined voting intentions based on party loyalty and property ownership. 

The ballot was not secret. Hence the expansion of Freehold housing did not guarantee the electoral success that the Whigs/Liberals had hoped for.

Today there are still around 370 residential addresses on the seven core streets of Freehold.  Some houses have been subdivided or converted and recently there have been a few new houses. The retail and commercial facilities in Freehold have evolved over the decades.  Nevertheless Freehold remains recognisably as it looked in the 1890s, a distinctive and popular part of Lancaster.

View from Derwent Road to the Castle

Text – Gordon  Clark. Published by Lancaster Civic Society (©2021). www.lancastercivicsociety.uk.

These guides were written by Gordon Clark for the Lancaster Civic Society and are available to members of the Society.

Gordon has written over sixty fascinating walks, guides and leaflets across a whole range of aspects relating to the Lancaster and Morecambe district.

Membership of the Society includes, not only these guides and walks, but also monthly talks and lectures on topics that people from the Lancaster district, and those with an interest in the area, are finding extremely engaging, as well as a series of walking guides around the area in the summer months with local historian Peter Wade.

Our next meeting is on 15th September – Visit to Morecambe Winter Gardens – Lecture about the Winter Gardens by Professor Vanessa Toulmin (Chair of the Winter Gardens Preservation Trust) followed by a guided tour of the building and ending with afternoon tea accompanied by Peter Jetson giving an organ recital. Members only for this event.

Interested in joining Lancaster Civic Society? Complete your details at our Contact & Join Us page

Proposed 9,000+ Homes in South Lancaster

CLOUD – Citizens of Lancaster Opposed to Unnecessary Development – issue press release highlighting their concerns.

Cloud have today issued a press release outlining their concerns, not only about the proposals for the 9,000+ homes proposed for south Lancaster, but also their criticism of the rushed and inadequate consultation.

Additionally they state “The whole process has been an indecent rush with the first two of the consultation events being announced 2 days in advance. For something as crucial as this to be scrabbling around in August for a supposed deadline on 30 August is surely bad practice.”

“Throughout we are reminded that the County is responsible for HIF and transport and the 9185 housing figure. When will residents be able to have an equivalent consultation with County. This is surely needed before 25 August to inform residents and City Councillors? This evening’s session was a welcome opportunity to ask questions of the City Council. What we now need is a joint City/County briefing and discussion session and before the City Council debate on 25 August. As Council tax payers we would be liable for cost overruns whether from City or County.”

The Housing Infrastructure Fund £140m is linked to 9,185 houses in South Lancaster over 25 years. That is a town the size of Darwen. This is what 9,000 houses looks like. Imagine this for South Lancaster

The full text of CLOUD press release reads:

South Lancaster housing development – Council rushing to a risky decision?

Local residents welcomed the opportunity provided by Council Leader Caroline Jackson for public discussion about the South Lancaster Growth Catalyst (SLGC), which includes the Bailrigg Garden Village development. Two briefing sessions were held on 4th and 11th August. They were the first time that residents were able to put key questions to council officers about the evidence for – and impact of – the 9,185 new houses proposed for south Lancaster. A special meeting of Lancaster City Council has been called for August 25th to decide whether to accept a Housing Infrastructure Fund grant which would cover part but not all the of the associated infrastructure costs.

However, the sessions raised more concerns and questions than answers. In particular :

● Residents asked repeatedly for evidence to support uplifting the housing target from 3,500 (agreed in the 2019 Local Plan) to the current figure of 9,185. This equates to a new town of 30,000 people – rather more than the population of Kendal! Council officers’ attempts to justify the 9,185 figure as only a ‘business case figure’ met with scepticism.

● The briefing sessions were told that housing developers would be expected to contribute to infrastructure costs through payment of a ‘roof tax’. The high level of such funding needed for south Lancaster, combined with evidence from other developments that developers find ways of reducing or even avoiding paying the tax altogether, led to real doubts that this amount of roof tax could be secured.

● There are very serious financial risks for the city council which it appears are only just beginning to be understood and made public. It would seem that any shortfalls on the massive £2610m budget would have to be picked up by council tax payers.

● The impact on already stretched local health provision was reported in the Lancaster Guardian on 22nd July 2021. Similar concerns surround the provision of schools for the additional residents of south Lancaster.

● It would seem that we would be facing 25 years of construction traffic as the south Lancaster development is expected to extend into the 2040s. It’s not hard to see why residents are so worried. ● And all this in the same week that the UN has published its Climate Change Report which will surely make Lancaster residents sit up and think about whether they want developers to concrete over a extensive greenfield site, increasing both carbon emissions and the risk of flooding in an area which has all too recently suffered as a result of extreme weather events.

● One final question – why the rush? The city council has been asked to meet on 25th August to take a final decision on whether to go ahead and approve the the HIF money. Given that there are still so many unanswered questions and Councillors are being asked to vote on the biggest strategic issue in the city for over 20 years, it seems almost farcical that a date in the middle of the holidays, when some councillors are likely to be away, has been chosen. The reason being given for the August date is a deadline of 30th August for the Council to sign the legally binding Partnership Agreement.

  • In view of the scale and gravity of this matter, the Cloud group is calling for the decision to be deferred until there has been an honest and open debate with the wider community – and for all concerned to be in possession of the full facts and evidence. After all at Full Council on 24 March 2021, a petition was tabled signed by 718 residents regarding the rushed nature of the Master Planning process. Janice Hanson, Deputy Leader of the Council, said that she recognised the frustration experienced by residents and accepted that substantive issues had been raised. She therefore made a recommendation.  Council was asked ‘to mandate that consultation on the subsequent South Lancaster Area Action Plan should include structured questions and provide feedback to those registering comments/objections’. This was seconded by Councillor Gina Dowding, who gave a strong critique of existing consultation problems. This was passed unopposed by Lancaster City Council. Surely time should now be provided for proper residents’ consultation over the HIF bid, in the spirit of that vote?  https://www.cloudbgv2017.co.uk/https://www.cloudbgv2017.co.uk/

https://www.cloudbgv2017.co.uk/

The Prospect of 9,000+ Homes in South Lancaster

An Open Statement by Lancaster Civic Society

Lancaster Civic Society are extremely disappointed about the lack of public consultation over the far-reaching implications of accepting Housing Infrastructure Fund monies. We fully appreciate that the resolution of many long-standing transportation issues depends on the receipt of this funding. However, we are of the view that there has been insufficient opportunity for a proper and robust engagement with the local community on this most important matter.

We cannot understand why it took until August for the City Council to engage with the local community on this issue, when it was considered by Cabinet on the 8th June. We find this delay baffling.

The subject of the report was not listed on the published agenda for the Cabinet on 8th June and it was taken as an urgent item. The City Council must have been in discussion with the County Council following their decisions on HIF in early 2021, it is therefore puzzling that it had to be dealt with as an urgent item.

Whilst the report was public, it contained an exempt appendix and the Cabinet was advised that the matter would be considered during the confidential part of the meeting. It is remarkable that the public report makes no reference to the obligation on the City Council to support the provision of over 9000 new dwellings in South Lancaster, as this is probably the most controversial aspect of the entire issue. The public report contains an options appraisal which we consider to be extremely superficial for an issue of this magnitude. We hope that the exempt appendix contained a more robust analysis for Cabinet members to consider

The justification used for dealing with the appendix as an exempt item was Schedule 12A, paragraph 3, of the Local Government Act 1972.This relates to the financial or business affairs of any particular person (including the authority holding that information). This could not apply to the specific issue of supporting the provision of over 9,000 new homes in South Lancaster, and the consequential planning implications of any such decision. This information is of considerable public interest and could have been included in the public report.

The report of 8th June provided an important opportunity for the City Council to properly articulate, in a public document, the arguments for and against accepting the HIF offer, particularly with regard to the obligation to facilitate over 9000 new homes. Had this happened there would have been ample time to consult on this and report back before making a final decision prior to the deadline of 30th August. We do not understand why the Council did not do this.

We consider the way the Council has handled this issue to be in contradiction of its previous commitments to meaningful community engagement.

On the 6th August 2019 the City Council Cabinet approved a report on the “establishment of Advisory Groups for Cabinet members to engage with communities and stakeholders”

The report stated that “The Cabinet has expressed its intention to establish a network of groups to facilitate meaningful engagement and discussion with communities and stakeholders…”

This was a very positive commitment on the part of the City Council to meaningful engagement with the local community, and the Council took this so seriously that it amended the constitution to reflect this new approach

However, the manner in which this issue has been dealt with falls very short of the commitment to “meaningful engagement and discussion” given in August 2019.

The City Council propose to take a decision on this issue on the 25th August. This decision is one of the most far reaching that the City Council has ever taken. To date the only opportunity for public engagement with the City Council on this critical issue has been two Teams sessions, the first lasting 70 minutes, the second an hour.

At both sessions there were significant numbers of questions from the public that could not be addressed in the time available.

At both Teams sessions it was stated that the Local Plan, which had been subject to considerable public consultation, had identified the possibility of significant additional new housing, and had stated that a minimum of 3,500 new homes would be provided in South Lancaster. It was stressed that that this had always been regarded as a minimum and not a target. The inference that we took from these comments was that the Local Plan consultation process had provided ample opportunity for public comment on the possibility of significant numbers of new houses in South Lancaster, and that no one should now be overly surprised by the suggestion of an uplift in the proposed number to over 9,000.

It is correct that the Local Plan Policy SC1 does state “a minimum of 3500” but it also contains the following paragraph

“Policy SP6 of this DPD sets out the overall housing target and identifies a wide range of development sites which will be required to meet that Local Housing Need. The broad location for growth has identified opportunities to deliver in the region of 3,500 new homes, 1,205 of which the Council believes can be realistically delivered during the course of this plan period up to 2034, due to the strategic infrastructure required to facilitate growth.”

You will note that this paragraph uses the phrase “in the region of 3500″

We would contend that the combined effect of these two phases within the Local Plan would have led any reader [and perhaps the Local Plan Inspector] to reasonably conclude that whist there might be more than 3500 new homes delivered in South Lancaster it would still be in the region of 3,500 i.e., a bit more, but certainly not 9,000+.

At both Teams sessions it was also asserted that the issues of the Local Plan and HIF were being wrongly “converged and conflated” However, in our view the two issues have become conflated. If the HIF agreement is signed, then this will partially predetermine future local plans. The City Council will be obliged to facilitate the provision of over 9,000 new homes in South Lancaster, which in turn will require the allocation, through the local planning process, of sufficient land to accommodate this. The only consideration [on this matter] for the local plan process will be to determine where these should be built.

We appreciate that the Council has been advised that it must sign the legally binding Partnership Agreement by 30th August. However, we believe that the County Council has until 2027 to spent the HIF grant. We cannot understand why a short extension to the identified deadline of 30th August to sign the Partnership Agreement could not be negotiated to allow time for meaningful consultation.

We would therefore urge the City Council to defer taking a decision on the 25th August to allow time for a public consultation exercise commensurate with the magnitude of this matter to the future of our city.

Lancaster Civic Society August 2021